NANA―ナナ― Volume 4 👩‍🎤

Volume 4 Discussion Thread

Start Date: 2025-05-20T15:00:00Z

NANA―ナナ― Reading Club Home Thread

Vocabulary Lists

Reading Schedule

Week Start Date Chapter
Week 1 June 21 第9話
Week 2 June 28 第10話
Week 3 July 5 第11話
Week 4 July 12 第12話

Discussion Rules

  • If you have any questions, don’t hesitate to ask.
  • Please mention the chapter and page number.
  • Please use spoiler tags for major events.
  • If you read ahead, please hold questions until during or after the appropriate week.
2 Likes

Chapter 9

Start Date: 2025-06-20T15:00:00Z

Participation

Mark your participation status by voting in this poll. (You can change your answer later if you’d like.)

  • I’m reading along
  • I’m still reading but I haven’t reached this section yet
  • I will catch up later
  • I’ve read this previously but I’m here for the discussion
  • I’m reading this after the book club has finished
0 voters
2 Likes
Chapter 9

Ah I should have known that the resolution was coming so soon, seeing the last page of chapter 8. So maybe nothing terrible will happen on the 5月5日 after all. Next date to watch out for will be the 5月26日 then! (also, 3rd time that they try to make us believe that Ren is here, it’s getting dangerous, might become a running gag :sweat_smile: )
Also, worth way to be dumped ever? Hi, you’re not the girlfriend sorry, you’re the ex, as here is my girlfriend.

5 Likes

I managed to get through chapter 9 with a lot of looking up words and a certain amount of googling and AI. But I am on vacation so we’ll see how it goes when I’m back at work. I certainly came in on a dramatic note!
I probably misunderstood some things, but I do have a couple of questions; if anyone can help, that would be great.

Page 7(?)

ハチ is talking about the weather. Even though the kanji 位 is used, this is the particle, right? Maybe like here: “Like it thinks it’s already summer, there are hot days, then like it’s going back to winter on it’s own, there are cold days.”

シン’s comment on that page was a bit too topical…

Page 47

Can anyone transcribe the hand written note? I can see a couple of kanji but…

6 Likes
p.7

Yes I believe 位, read くらい, means “to the point / degree that”
[もう夏かと思う位] is qualifying [暑い日], → “hot days to the point that you would think is it summer already?”,
[冬に戻るのかって位] is qualifying [寒い日], → "cold days to the point that you would think is winter back already? "

p.47

Oh that’s a tough one. I remember I told myself that it would be nice if I tried to transcribe it. Thanks for the push :grin:
あんた 宛に
?った ??
住所変更くらい
ちゃんとしなさい

Missing a lot from the second line :confused:
But I’m pretty sure it says: “those have arrived for you. please make sure to properly set up your change of address”, basically her mom telling her that she’s pissed that she had to forward her her mail order :sweat_smile:

Well done making it through the chapter and let us know if there are any more questions, I will be happy to help!

5 Likes

Thanks for the page 7 translation, @Akashelia. Seems like I had the basic idea but your translation seems clearer.

Page 47

For line two maybe 届いた書留? “Arrived registered mail”. That would fit with the translation you have.

I’m sure I’ll have more questions, thanks!

6 Likes

Yeah I think that’s it, fits perfectly!!

5 Likes
chapter 9

Nana is quickly becoming my new favorite yuri manga :joy::rofl::upside_down_face:



Honestly, I don’t know what Junko is on about here.


I’m not saying that Hachi is the easiest person to be in a relationship with (platonically, even), but expecting her to change who she is so that Shoji doesn’t cheat on her is completely out of line, imo. He knew who he was dating the whole time, it’s on him if he’s decided that he needs or wants something else.

Random other thoughts:
:thought_balloon:I’m not for violence but Nana ready to punch out Shoji made me start crushing on her now. :joy:
:thought_balloon:Nana just calling Hachi’s mom “Natsuko” (another na name!) is hilarious and so in character.
:thought_balloon:I hadn’t really noticed it before, but the Trapnest poster had everyone but Ren looking to the side so that he’s just staring directly at you. It’s really good for all of the emotional moments that Yazawa sensei loves to use it for.
:thought_balloon:Nana on the toilet when the tickets arrive made me laugh way harder than it should have :rofl:

5 Likes

Chapter 10

Start Date: 2025-06-27T15:00:00Z

Participation

Mark your participation status by voting in this poll. (You can change your answer later if you’d like.)

  • I’m reading along
  • I’m still reading but I haven’t reached this section yet
  • I will catch up later
  • I’ve read this previously but I’m here for the discussion
  • I’m reading this after the book club has finished
0 voters
2 Likes

Nooo, I fell behind!

3 Likes

I’m looking forward to your reaction to chapter 9!

4 Likes
ch9, p35

蓮 fake-out #6237

Really mad.

3 Likes

:joy: don’t rage quit pls :slight_smile:

3 Likes
ch9

Well 淳子 can go fuck herself I guess. She has the right to remain friend with 障子 of course, but gaslighting 奈々 into believing that it’s kinda her fault to that he cheated on her? Garbage behaviour IMO.

4 Likes

Yes :face_holding_back_tears: now on to chapter 10!

4 Likes
p60

Weird kanji:

2 Likes
ch10

That was a long chapter but I really liked it. A lot of great drawings. 京助 turns out to be better at dealing with the breakup than 淳子 (although seemingly for sexist reasons? Oh well).

The concert was really fun. The drawings of them on stage are so cool, they really convey the ビジュアル well.

After that we have some good conflict and character growth. Looking forward to next chapter.

4 Likes
Chapter 10

I really liked this chapter too.
Junko being told how poorly she handled the situation.
Shouji trying to disappear from the manga because he knows everyone hates him now, but not being allowed too.


Hachi’s cold reaction to the break up, and warm feelings for Nana.

The first meeting with Misato for Hachi and her wondering what was going on there, while at the same time teaming up to gather a crowd before the concert.
The concert.

Then the rest of the chapter was more painful to read, seeing Hachi hurting and hurting Nana back :frowning:

4 Likes
ナナ

I do think ナナ may have needed something like that though. We don’t really know what she’s up to at this point (besides the band stuff of course) but she doesn’t seem to have processed the whole Ren thing and appears to be toying with people while she’s having fun and then pushing them away when things get serious.

The weird relationship she has with 美里 seems unhealthy for the both of them frankly. The whole “I called her to tell her there was a concert but didn’t expect her to come” is very unconvincing. I don’t think 奈々 was very diplomatic when she put her foot down but hopefully it can lead to positive change down the line.

It’s amusing that 奈々 is now the grown-up in the relationship.

3 Likes
美里

Forgot to write that I was a bit shocked to learn that Misato was only 17. As far as I remember Nana was 16 or 17 in volume 1, when Misato was already leading the fan club!?

3 Likes