NANA―ナナ― Volume 3 👩‍🎤

Volume 3 Discussion Thread

Start Date: 2025-05-16T15:00:00Z

NANA―ナナ― Reading Club Home Thread

Vocabulary Lists

Reading Schedule

Week Start Date Chapter
Week 1 May 17 第5話
Week 2 May 24 第6話
Week 3 May 31 第7話
Week 4 June 14 第8話

Discussion Rules

  • If you have any questions, don’t hesitate to ask.
  • Please mention the chapter and page number.
  • Please use spoiler tags for major events.
  • If you read ahead, please hold questions until during or after the appropriate week.
1 Like

Chapter 5

Start Date: 2025-05-16T15:00:00Z

Participation

Mark your participation status by voting in this poll. (You can change your answer later if you’d like.)

  • I’m reading along
  • I’m still reading but I haven’t reached this section yet
  • I will catch up later
  • I’ve read this previously but I’m here for the discussion
  • I’m reading this after the book club has finished
0 voters
2 Likes

I like that 奈々 seems to sincerely wants for ナナ to succeed and become famous in a completely disinterested way. She doesn’t hope to ride get coattails or anything.

奈々 is overly meddlesome but her sincerity always ends up winning me over.

2 Likes
p21

Also for those of you reading digitally, I think it’s worth posting this here because I love 奈々’s made up 幸子’s lore:

5 Likes

What can you do, like every doggo, she’s the best <3

p.21

Yes バーチャルサチコ has very specific tastes!

5 Likes
第五話

I like 障子 leaning into the joke when he fatefully meets the real 幸子.

Also the interview of the 美少年 is filled with fun interactions, I especially enjoyed the 山田さん(年齢不詳) version of the running gag. Amusing that he feels like gatekeeping 奈々 for being a member of the fanclub without knowing that he also plays the bass. Ok poseur.

I wonder when 奈々 will discover the truth about the relationship between 蓮 and ナナ. Looking forward to that. Also more Yuri bait. I approve.

4 Likes

Hehe loving reading your impressions! Yes a lot of things to look forward to! I am really happy to be linking this manga so much with a re-read. As you point out, it’s all the little interactions that are so much fun. Doesn’t hurt that I enjoy the main plot line, but it’s just a very fun read and I love all the characters! (though no one as close to 奈々, you can see how easily she pulls everyone into her universe of madness with 幸子 and the big demon king, who even had to manifest a real 幸子)

4 Likes

Yeah I struggled a bit with the first volume, the Japanese was difficult for me and I didn’t really understand where this was going, but it’s really coming into its own now. It’s like a good sitcom.

4 Likes

Nice! I feel like we are still a bit in the introduction phase (settling in, getting a job, recruiting new band members and the like, which goes conveniently really fast)), but at the same time the show has already started!

3 Likes

Can’t wait to enter the 奈々 becomes a tambourine international superstar arc.

4 Likes

Chapter 6

Start Date: 2025-05-23T15:00:00Z

Participation

Mark your participation status by voting in this poll. (You can change your answer later if you’d like.)

  • I’m reading along
  • I’m still reading but I haven’t reached this section yet
  • I will catch up later
  • I’ve read this previously but I’m here for the discussion
  • I’m reading this after the book club has finished
0 voters
1 Like
Chapter 6

Lots of fun moments in this chapter! Like how Hachi has just spent all her money already, or how she thinks that Nana’s job is probably at an SMクラブ or the like, how she thought her boss wanted to confess to her when really he wanted to fire her, and Shouji’s brand new 2001 PC.

Not sure what Hachi means p.55?

Funny how when Hachi thinks about what counts as cheating, we immediately jump to seeing Shouji and Sachiko together x)

Story wise, lots of things too! Shin is apparently a baby, Yasu is back, Nana’s money problem seems to be solved but she is now unemployed, and Shouji and Sachiko seem to have become dangerously close :open_mouth:

New vocab of note:
現ナマ
ガングロ (with Jun’s skin showed as almost black, that was a fun one x) )
畳む
余談

3 Likes
p70

でも希望者 出たって言ってなかったっけ

There are three layers of quotations in this sentence (if you count っけ as a sort of self-quotation).

1 Like
ch6

I enjoyed the ghost of adulting:

It’s also the second time I get a Ren fake-out, this time with アッさん.

Didn’t follow the logic either. I think maybe she’s just implying that there’s nothing she can do about her situation because “it’s not like she’s a queen” or something.

It already came up on a previous chapter but I enjoy 野垂れ死に.

I also struggled to understand the very last page with the 嫁 thing because I wasn’t familiar with the これと言う idiom.

3 Likes

Chapter 7

Start Date: 2025-05-30T15:00:00Z

Participation

Mark your participation status by voting in this poll. (You can change your answer later if you’d like.)

  • I’m reading along
  • I’m still reading but I haven’t reached this section yet
  • I will catch up later
  • I’ve read this previously but I’m here for the discussion
  • I’m reading this after the book club has finished
0 voters
2 Likes

I didn’t post the new thread because I think we’re the only two still reading along, I thought maybe the others could use a break to catch up.

But also I was curious to see what would happen so I already read ahead…

ch7

I like that Nana’s mum has the face of somebody used to deal with Nana’s shenanigans:

Also we got a nice example of a proper ガン黒 with 奈美ちゃん. I wonder what the third sister looks like.

4 Likes

Yes that was my thinking too, and I knew you knew so didn’t bother with the heads up :slight_smile:

I guess technically you have read on time, it’s just my post that’s late :smiley:

I debated that and we still have 80+ chapters to go (not really liking to write it that way because it sounds like it’s a chore and I really don’t think it is!). I’m just thinking that I don’t think I want to take more than 2 years to read the series, if we take break frequently I fear that this might happen. And also I am a bit reluctant to slow down because I love reading this manga and already wish that we could be reading more of it, so I guess a very selfish stand. On the other hand, I agree that it is a pity that we have lost so many readers. Hmm, what to do…

3 Likes
ch7

Ok I finished. Dense chapter. I hope it means that the 障子 arc is nearing its end, I prefer ナナX奈々 shenanigans.

淳子 is still great though, I hope she’ll remain a side character.

3 Likes
Chapter 7 replies

Haha yes. Also I like that they have all 奈 names. 奈津美、奈々、奈美, and the last one is probably a 奈 too.

Felt hard for me too! I understood the gist (障子 strangled 幸子 to death so she couldn’t resist him anymore) but will have to reread with look ups to understand what they are actually saying.

2 Likes
Chapter 7 vocab of note

出戻り娘 - daughter who moves back to her parents after divorcing (they use 出戻る in the chapter but I found this definition on Jisho and think it’s also a good fit x) )
ザル / 笊 - strong drinker
代返 - answer a roll call for another
臨機応変 - adapting oneself to the requirements of the moment
あわよくば - if circumstances permit
二股かける - to play it both ways

Understood much better with those words under my belt!

Me too :grin: this one was great:

A bit cruel, but afterwards she tells her that she will become famous and make lots of money so she can buy her the house of her dreams and have her in the dog house in the garden, so all good!

3 Likes