Slam Dunk Informal Book Club & Appreciation Thread

Thank you so much!! Can’t wait to see you guys there〜

2 Likes

Volume 3 thread is up! Anyone let me know if you need any more volume threads

:star2: :basketball_man: :basketball:

2 Likes

Good day kind @mitrac, may I please be spared a volume 14 thread?? Vol 14 is chapters 117-125
Ahh and actually also vol 15 if you don’t mind? My current volume is THICK haha. Vol 15 has chapters 126-134
Thank you kindly!!

This summer and fall were really busy, and I was out and about a lot so I feel like I’ve read mostly only digital manga recently. So I’m sORRY SLAM DUNK, but now I’m back to reading it mwehehehe

I guess this isn’t completely related, but maybe just enough?

Basketball Adjacent Ramble

But, one of the things I was busy with was an international trip to Spain!! For the first week I was with some friends who moved there, and they took me to their weekly basketball night!!! It was honestly one of my favorite nights of the whole trip haha! I told them I was going to be really terrible, because I mainly only play and practice by myself with no one else to play with. But they assured me that some of the other people there aren’t that great either :joy: and they just have fun.
But actually, it ended up being a really solid group/players and we had a really good time! AND I WAS ACTUALLY ABLE TO BE USEFUL TO MY TEAM! My friends were very impressed that I could actually play, and didn’t completely suck, and that made me so happy :sob: I surpassed the bare minimum let’s goooo

But it was a really beautiful area too!! It was a full outdoor court, we had it all to ourselves, and we played as the sun set, and there was just a massive mountain range, RIGHT THERE. We don’t have mountains where I live, so :smiling_face_with_tear: it was beautiful

But yeah, that was honestly one of my favorite days of the trip hahaha

I am.
バスケットマン。:man_bouncing_ball:

2 Likes

I recently read through Slam Dunk (as someone with 0 interest in basketball or sports, and as someone who doesn’t read much manga either, but it had come highly recommended so decided to give it a shot. pun intended) and it’s literally become my favourite manga. It’s so good! Highly recommend to anyone considering reading!

3 Likes

yay, welcome back!! The posts are up - here’s a quick link to Ch 14 for you to get started :slight_smile: :basketball:

:smiling_face_with_tear: whaaat an amazing experience, and glad you wrote about it here! That sounds so, so… well just so fun and amazing and warm and fuzzy all at once. Love how you signed off the trip report :star2:

awesome review, I’m so glad you found the thread!!! I also only picked it up due to it being highly recommended. welcome to the fun and hope to see you around here :slight_smile:

2 Likes

Volume 4 thread is up!

Go :hash::one::zero:!! :star_struck:

2 Likes

Started my next volume a few days ago!
No rush @mitrac, but when you get a second can I have threads for volumes 16 and 17 pleaseee

Volume 16: Chapters 135-143
Volume 17: Chapters 144-152

Thank youu :pray:

2 Likes

New volumes are up! It’s so fun to see how much you’re loving the volumes that are way ahead of me and Prath.

Bizarrely, I can’t update the homepost, it tells me I can’t update the poll after 5 minutes, but I didn’t try changing the poll? So use these links for now and I’m hoping that’s just a temporary glitch and I’ll update the homepost later

Volume 16: Ch 135-143
Volume 17: Ch 144-152

2 Likes

Yippee! Thank you!

Haha, I am really really enjoying them :grimacing: Most of the excited screaming is contained within the spoiler chapter sections haha

In good news, it’s finally getting warmer where I live, so I’ll be able to play basketball again!! Wahoo :partying_face:

2 Likes

@Mods I’m sorry to tag you, it seems something is broken on Discourse (issue below: it thinks I’m modifying a poll when I’m not) and I was wondering if you could flag a report to Discourse? Or if you’re already aware of an issue/fix?

I just wanted to add a link to the home post, but I can’t update the above home post, whereas other thread updates work. The difference I noticed is there are emojis in the polls here, and the error I get says the polls can’t be updated (I didn’t make any poll changes though). I’m told the emojis on Discourse updated recently due to copyright reasons but the id stayed the same. I don’t know if it’s related to that, but I definitely didn’t used to have any issue updating this post.


Interestingly, it still logs each time I attempt to update the home post even though it didn’t actually change anything.

Any help appreciated! Thank you!

3 Likes

Hey there! Sorry to hear this is happening. I’ll share this info with Discourse and see if they have any suggestions to offer.

4 Likes

That’s so nice, thank you!

3 Likes

Someone from Discourse got back to us and told us that this is expected behaviour:

“By default, Discourse does not allow editing a poll after 5 minutes of creation. This behavior is due to how votes are reset whenever a poll is edited, as a safeguard to maintain vote integrity.”

They also told us that the message will appear for any post containing a poll even if you aren’t editing the poll per se.

3 Likes

Thank you for checking!

That’s a very strange response, because I have been editing this post for a year (>> 5 minutes :sweat_smile:) with no problem despite the polls. And many other posts with polls. This is the first time I’ve had a problem, and the other posts with polls still allow edits. :confused:

It seems the actual behavior of polls is not necessarily what Discourse is expecting.

3 Likes

Strange indeed, I’ll let Discourse know and we’ll see what they say.

3 Likes

you’re a star, thank you so so much!

2 Likes

Hey again! We heard back from Discourse and they said again that if you’re seeing the message, “You cannot change a poll after the first … minutes.” when editing your post, it’s because the edit would reset the vote counts — even if you’re not directly changing the poll.

They also said that if you’ve been able to edit similar posts before, it’s likely because those changes didn’t trigger a reset in votes. We know you did the following, but for the sake of relaying the info, here’s a suggestion they offered:

If your user is still having trouble editing posts containing polls, they will need to ensure that the edits they are making to the post do not impact the poll.

Just to double check, is this the only post you’re experiencing this issue on or does it happen to every post with a poll?

3 Likes

To add to Rachel’s post, Discourse staff told us they haven’t touched this feature and its settings lately. We’ve also never changed the settings either from 5 mins to something else.

But after 5 mins, you’re able to edit it right? We’ll leave the setting as is unless this becomes a bigger issue for more users.

3 Likes

I took a look at mitrac’s post and one thing I noticed is that the emoji are typed in as actual emoji - like an actual U+1F4E3 :megaphone: character instead of :megaphone: which Discourse then turns into :megaphone: . Similarly the microphone is an actual U+1F3A4 :microphone: character instead of :microphone:

In particular, I think it might be :megaphone: that is the problem. Previously it would have been converted to :mega: :mega: but now it’s converted to :megaphone: (possibly since this commit but the large modifications break the github UI). So I think since :mega: isn’t :megaphone: it thinks you’re trying to edit the poll.

@mitrac If my theory is right, I think it might allow you to edit the post if you swap the megaphone emoji with the :mega: code for an emoji.

EDIT: I did a view source and it looks like the previous value was :loudspeaker: :loudspeaker: not :mega: - So maybe you might need to change it to :loudspeaker:

3 Likes

Thanks for your help RachelG and Jen and araigoshi!

I can confirm I’m making edits that don’t affect the polls. I was previously (before the Discourse emoji update) able to modify this post.

This is the only post I’m having trouble with. For example, I can modify this one and it has polls (no emoji in polls)

That setting can remain and wasn’t generally causing me an issue, the problem seems to be the emoji updated and the post is registering that as a change.

Is there a way to temporarily (on your end) allow me to make changes to the poll and delete the emojis? Or if that’s not possible, does Discourse have any other solutions for me to regain editing abilities of this post?

Oh thank you for looking at that! Yes you’re right, when I open the post for editing I see the emoji not the :microphone: etc, oh dear, I guess my ignorance on that caused this

I tried swapping out the loudspeaker (nice idea) as you suggested, but unfortunately that doesn’t work. I also tried both the loudspeaker and microphone just in case but that gave the same error.

2 Likes