Please help me create Japanese _sentence_ diagrams for beginners

I was only really talking about this example (I didn’t actually read the rest until now :smile:):

あたし ゼッテー(よご)れた(かね) 使(つか)わないのが主義(しゅぎ)なんだ

That seems to be a clear example of nesting to me:

As for me ◯

enter the nested sub-clause in the circle

As for dirty money ◯

now push down to the actual subject clause in this circle

I have a strict rule to never use [it].

I think the dotted line thing may be able to make this clear in a diagram. I’m still working on how to visually represent it clearly.

I think I understand the point you’re making. In particular, your point that も is inclusive while は is contrasting/disambiguating/specifying is a good one.

My (possibly incorrect) understanding of the grammatical term “topic” is that it’s basically context. The over-simplified English loose-equivalent might be “as for ◯, …” where the circle marks a topic.

So I’m not sure I agree that all your examples aren’t topics as I understand them:

As for [being] in Venice, …

The topic is “in Venice”.

As for the rumor about him, …

The topic is “the rumor about him”.

(Please correct me if I’m misreading any of this.)

Fortunately, I’ve talked to the mods, and they’ve marked this thread as non-mandatory for participation.

:wink:

I’ve written elsewhere about experts like yourself sometimes not being the best teachers. This is a thread for (and by) beginners trying to feel their way forward. Like it or not, over-simplifications are a time-honored and proven form of pedagogy.

You may enjoy this thread that I linked to in the OP much more than this one.

4 Likes