🎎 日本の歴史まんが Week 4

日本の歴史 1 日本のはじまり

日本の歴史 1 日本のはじまり Home
Intermediate Manga Club Home

Week 4

Start Date: August 9
Previous Part: 🎎 日本の歴史まんが Week 3
Next Part: 🎎 日本の歴史まんが Week 5

Reading:

Week Start Date Chapter and part Page numbers Number of pages
4 August 9 Chapter 2, part 2 86-113 28

Discussion Guidelines

  • Please use spoiler tags for major events in the current chapter and any content from future chapters.
  • When asking for help, please mention the page number. If your version doesn’t have page numbers some other point of context could be helpful.
  • Don’t be afraid to ask questions! All of us are here to learn and help each other.
  • Please join in the conversation, and let’s have fun!

Participation

Mark your participation status by voting in this poll.
  • I’m reading along
  • I’m reading ahead
  • I haven’t reached this part yet
  • I’m reading on my own schedule
  • I’m reading after the club has ended
  • I’m just here for the discussion :popcorn:
0 voters
Keep track of your progress in this poll!
  • I haven’t read this section yet
  • I’m reading this section
  • I have finished reading this section
0 voters

Don’t forget to set this thread to Watching in order to keep up with the discussion!

week 4

A sobering reminder that, in real life, bullies often end up on the winning side of history…

At least nowadays we’re more civilized and wouldn’t allow such a thing.

I thought Shiro was a girl and that she was supposed to be Kuro’s love interest :sweat_smile: It wasn’t until he offered him his daughter that I realised it was a guy haha

Though I did wonder about Shiro’s increasingly masculine face as ‘she’ was growing up lol

I feel like the primary tension driving this chapter never really gets addressed by its end…

Hah, same here, though I started to twig at the “increasingly masculine face” bit. Realised on re-consulting the start of the chapter that he was introduced as 大陸から来た少年, which might have been a bit of a clue…

Yeah, it’s Yumi and Hajime from the Joumon period all over again. So much tension, and then…time skip, everyone is dead. I know the characters and their conflicts are just there to highlight the historical developments, but it’s still getting frustrating to never get a proper resolution.

Ngl, I was surprised older Shiro didn’t drop a line like, “The moon was beautiful when we were younger.”

Yeah based on the first page of the chapter (and the precedent set by chapter 1) I assumed it would be a boy/girl story again so I paid extra attention when the character was introduced. Especially since I regularly struggle to identify the gender of people in manga… If they don’t have facial hair it’s a coin flip basically.

I’m mildly amused by the fact that when クロ goes to the dark side he doesn’t just get desensitized to violence towards other humans, but also turns into a total megalomaniac. That doesn’t seem like a particularly realistic character development to me, but reading him as an allegory for how the culture developed (or rather, is believed to have developed) it kind of makes sense.

I kind of thought シロ was going to represent another aspect of culture in that time (like a group that were pacifists) but then … nothing happened.

Oh well! Next chapter has ()! So I’m really excited about that.

Also, I miiiiiight be the proud new owner of 15 volumes of manga history. :sweat_smile: So keep your eyes peeled for an offshoot poll if you’re interested in that kind of thing. :smiley:

Characters

Idk, there was a time skip of at least two decades at some point, and people can just change a lot in that amount of time. Especially as people started to treat Kuro like their leader more and more, I don’t think it’s unrealistic for something like that to go to someone’s head.. But the rapid changes to society were probably a condensed version of something that happened over several generations.

I thought he might represent some sort of scientific advancement, because he kept talking about studying the stars. But nothing came of that, either. I also felt a little sad that Kuro’s daughter got introduced and then dropped two pages later. Guess she was forced to become the child bride of one of his toxically masculine retainers.

Well, at least Shiro didn’t marry that little girl…

Oh yes same! Maybe in the next chapter someone will bring back the stars thing?

Now it’s time for…

Stuff I googled!

逆茂木

物見やぐら

This picture was from this delightfully old-internet site. You can also kind of see the moat part in the picture.

主祭殿
Kind of just looks like a bigger watchtower.

装飾品




This looks most similar to what he was wearing but not exactly like the manga.

I love all the people who go above and beyond and find me cool things related to the reading that I don’t have to Google for myself :blush:

My secret is I have a lot of downtime at my job so I might as well just google random stuff :joy: I also enjoyed reading Around the World in 80 Days and googling every place that they went to, where it is on the map, and looking at pictures.

Thanks for all the pics @soggyboy , really nice!

物見やぐら

Getting Asterix vibes from that one!

Well, I mean, there’s only so many ways you can stick a bunch of tree trunks upright in a bunch of dirt. :slightly_smiling_face: