Week 19: サイレント・ウィッチ 🤫 🧙‍♀️

Join the Intermediate Book Club here!
Silent Witch :shushing_face: :woman_mage: Home Thread

Week 19

Start Date: May 10
Previous Part: Week 18

Reading:

Week Chapter End page End % End on Page Count
19 シークレット・エピソード
+ ここまでの登場人物
+ あとがき
293 100% End of book 23

Discussion Rules

  • Please use spoiler tags for major events in the current chapter(s) and any content in future chapters.
  • When asking for help, please mention the chapter and page number. Also mention what version of the book you are reading.
  • Don’t be afraid of asking questions, even if they seem embarrassing at first. All of us are here to learn.
  • To you lurkers out there: Join the conversation, it’s fun! :durtle_the_explorer:

Participants

Mark your participation status by voting in this poll.
(Please feel free to update your status whenever you like!)

  • I’m reading along
  • I have finished this part
  • I’m still reading the book but I haven’t reached this part yet
  • I’m no longer reading the book
  • I’m reading this book after the club has ended
0 voters

If you’ve already read this book but are still going to join the discussion, please select “I have finished this part.”

Proper nouns

Name Note
ケルベック伯爵領
ウォーガン山脈
リディル王国
アガサ 侍女
イザベル・ノートン ケルベック伯爵令嬢
アラン 馬丁、アガサの弟
シェフィールド 風の精霊王
モニカ・エヴァレット 沈黙の魔女
ネロ
アニー
ミネルヴァ school
ルイス・ミラー 結界の魔術師
リィンズベルフィード (リン) 風の上位精霊
ライオネル 第一王子, 27 yo
フェリクス 第二王子, 18 yo
アルバート 第三王子, 14 yo
セレンディア学園
クロックフォード公爵 第二王子の祖父
ダスティン・ギュンター 作家
ロザリー・ミラー ルイスの妻
アーロン・オブライエン 生徒会会計
エリオット・ハワード 生徒会書記
ブリジェット・グレイアム 生徒会書記
ニール・クレイ・メイウッド 生徒会庶務
シリル・アシュリー 生徒会副会長
(フェリクス・アーク・リディル) 第二王子、生徒会長
ヴィクター・ソーンリー 先生
ラナ・コレット 2年生
セルマ・カーシュ 保健委員
カロライン
ウィルディアヌ トカゲ
ハイオーン侯爵 シリルの養父
エマニュエル・ダーウィン 〈宝玉の魔術師〉
バーソロミュー・アレクサンダー MC of Dustin Gunther’s adventure books

Don’t forget to set this thread to Watching in order to stay abreast of discussion!

5 Likes

I finished it! It was fun :slight_smile:

Summary

Now we know better what Luis think of Monica. I don’t like いじわる pay, but at least he truly respects her and places above himself.

And it is clear that Felix doesn’t know yet who Monica is. But the way he thinks about her, I suspect that there will be romance in the future books.

8 Likes
The end

This was a much more satisfying ending than the last regular chapter and first epilogue.
It was fun seeing Louis’s and Felix’s views about each other and their respective political camps. Shed a bit more light upon the political situation in the country as well. And we finally got an explanation why Monica was left at the school, even though it looked like her guarding job was over. It was actually an open-ended surveillance job all along.

That actually didn’t feel entirely clear to me. But after reading the way he thinks about the Silent Witch, I’m now no longer completely sure he isn’t the prologue from the first chapter, either.

This was fun a fun read, all in all, and I’ll probably pick up volume 2 at some point. Thanks for organizing, @Redglare.

10 Likes
Thoughts

So I found the last line of the chapter intriguing… until I started writing this comment. I thought レディ・エヴァレット was a different first name, like Felix had been brainwashed into thinking the Silent Witch had a name other than Monica or something. Would make for some good theorizing. But turns out it’s just “lady”? That’s a lot less fun. :sweat_smile:

8 Likes
Play-by-play + replies

奥様のご懐妊おめでとうございます。
お子さんが生まれた時のお祝いの品は、数学の入門書で良いでしょうか?
ルイスさんのお好きな数学書があったら、教えてください。

It’s only 3 lines in and it’s already a very good report.

だけど、精神干渉術式は完璧ではなかったので、

Apply ice magic to burnt area.

そこをわたしが現行犯で捕まえました。ちょっとやりすぎました。ごめんなさい。

“I caught him. Also I overdid something but refuse to elaborate. Sorry!”

ただ、ことあるごとに「豚が……豚が……」と謎のうわごとを繰り返しているとかなんとか。

Looks like he was also captivated by the beauty of Mr. Sam’s pig’s numerical series! :smiling_face_with_tear:

モニカ・エヴァレットの思考回路は、ルイスにはどうにも理解不能である。

I recommend reading “Secrets of the Silent Witch” for a deeper understanding.

「何故、第二王子の護衛を〈沈黙の魔女〉殿に依頼したのですか?」

Are we really getting an answer to this?!

魔術は高威力、広範囲だったり、追尾などの特殊効果があると、それだけ詠唱が長くなる。
それなのに〈沈黙の魔女〉は、高威力かつ広範囲で、しかも特殊効果がてんこ盛りの魔術を無詠唱でやってのけたのだ。

…I guess something slipped through the book edits, huh?

edit: See replies.

だから少しでもモニカに自信を持たせようと、ウォーガンの黒竜退治に引きずっていったのに、黒竜を撃退した後は、逃げるように山小屋に引きこもる始末。

Hum. “I want her to get more confidence because seeing someone who is so much better at magic than me deprecate herself so much frankly hurts me.” is at least a much better reason than “I enjoy her suffering”

「陛下は私に『第二王子を内密に護衛せよ』と命じましたけどね、私は陛下のお言葉を額面通りに受け取ってはいないのですよ……『第二王子を秘密裏に監視せよ』──それが、陛下の本音だと私は思っています」

Hum hum. And if that’s the case, it would make sense to give that order to someone who is not part of the second prince’s faction.

Are we solving all mysteries in this chapter that came after the epilogue? :laughing:

人当たりの良い柔らかな笑顔の下に、何かおぞましいものが蠢いているような──そういった不気味さをルイスはフェリクスに感じた。

Wow. “Like something repulsive/disgusting is squirming under the surface of that smiling face” is probably the most graphic and most damning description we ever got of Felix.

「つまり、強い者である第二王子と〈沈黙の魔女〉殿を、同時にいじめてやろうと」
ルイスは正解とは言わず、ただニッコリと美しく微笑む。

I guess despite what we learnt previously the fact that he enjoys the struggles he inflicts on Monica doesn’t change. He calls it “bullying the strong”, but it just feels vindictive.

「納得しました。ルイス殿の評価を『強い者いじめが好きな性格破綻者』に訂正いたします」

Also he absolutely deserves Rin.

フェリクスが紅茶を飲み干すと、侍従に化けたウィルディアヌが控えめに口を挟んだ。

I wonder how much you can choose who becomes your (?) spirit, or if it’s more of a “you get what you get” thing. ウィルディアヌ seems perfectly suited for a prince, making me think that that is probably no coincidence. Nero is a good match for Monica, although he sometimes feels a bit more pushy than Monica would probably like if she could’ve chosen. Rin seems far more cheeky than I’d expect of someone Louis has chosen himself.

ソーンリー教諭を逮捕した〈結界の魔術師〉は、さぞクロックフォード公爵に恨まれていることだろう。

Not catching that guy would’ve made it much worse over time for the academy though? Or I guess maybe Crockford would’ve liked to catch him himself without making it public.

「あぁ、そろそろ尻尾を出す頃だと思っていたのだけど、獲物を横取りされたようだ。〈結界の魔術師〉は、私の周囲を嗅ぎまわっているからね。その過程で、ソーンリーの犯罪に気づいたのだろう」
冷ややかな声で呟き、フェリクスはポケットから小さなブローチを取り出した。

Ooooooh. I wonder if he destroyed the thing himself on purpose?!

だからフェリクスはブローチを貰ってすぐに、ウィルディアヌに命じて破壊させたのだ。

:slight_smile:

We’re really solving all the mysteries in this “after the epilogue” chapter.

なんにせよ、しばらくは慎重に動いた方が良いだろう。

So… I guess there is actually something to hide, then. Nice.

「あぁ、どうせ七賢人を監視役に仕向けるなら、〈結界の魔術師〉より、あの人にしてくれればいいのに」

It’s him! It’s him after all! He’s the blue-eyed guy in the prologue who was fascinated by Monica’s magic!!

「ウォーガンの黒竜を撃退し、翼竜の群れを一瞬で撃墜した、この国の英雄。世界でただ一人の無詠唱魔術の使い手である、千年に一人の天才魔術師……」

Yessssssss!

It’s fun that he’s independently fascinated by her twice, even if (or especially because?) both feelings differ by a lot :laughing:

また、加筆修正するにあたって、全体的にWeb版よりもモニカに優しい修正がされています。

?!??!?!??!?

I guess that is his one redeeming quality.

Agreed. The epilogue didn’t even provoke any live-tweeting reactions from me. It wasn’t bad, but this was definitely more interesting.

Did it? I don’t remember any new information we got apart from “the king probably wants to watch the second prince”.

Am I misunderstanding that second sentence? Because I think he absolutely, 100%, without a doubt is that guy from the prologue. And for that reason alone I think that he doesn’t know yet who Monica is; he clearly isn’t directing that fanboyish zeal towards the Monica that he knows.

Let me know if there’s anything fun I missed in the character portraits. I gave the first four a very cursory read, and decided that it’s probably not worth the effort to read them without added furigana and Yomichan lookups. (And then I threw the afterword into ChatGPT because I’m definitely not sifting through that to find out whether it contains anything interesting.)

Thanks for suggesting this book and organizing the book club, @Redglare. I enjoyed the book a lot and I’ll definitely read volume 2 at some point… though probably once it’s easier for me to read L30 books. I only struggled through this because it was fun to read, but it was still a struggle!

And thanks to everyone participating in the threads! A fun book is only half of what makes a book club great :heart:

I left my thoughts of the book as a review over on Natively. Overall I thought it was quite fun, with a few wrinkles of various sizes. Especially less bullying would’ve been nice. And more Isabelle, of course. And… I was hoping that only the first book would be academy-based, but alas.

Also… I finished my first L30! And my first IBC! :partying_face:

11 Likes
Response

What did? Is there a typo or something?

Or perhaps he’s exactly what she needs!

6 Likes
Reply

I guess I was a bit tired. I misread the end of the first sentence and thought it was basically repeating the whole “Monica cast a high-powered special effects spell without chanting” twice in different words.

Oh, definitely!

6 Likes

My thoughts about the book -

Another rambling theory....with some evidence to support it

What if this isn’t the real Felix we are seeing? What if Felix is “Felix”?

  1. The King’s original request: Louis explains 「第二王子を秘密裏に監視せよ」―それが陛下の本音だと私は思っています。」Originally, the task assigned to Louis by the King was to protect the 2nd prince because he was in danger. But the unusual twist was that the King specifically told Louis he was not allowed to let the prince know he was being protected. What reason could the king have? Was it because the King suspected something about the Second prince? Was it because the King didn’t want word to get back to Duke Crockford (the Second Prince’s supporter with major influence on Selendia Academy)?

    What if the danger to Felix is ongoing and in fact already underway? If the “Felix” that we see interacting with the student council, Monica etc, is not actually Felix, then it would make sense. And the danger to the second prince has already occurred because the real prince is somewhere else (imprisoned?) and the one who looks like Felix is actually someone else: A magician who used magic to transform themselves into the likeness of Felix. つまり、”Felix”, not Felix.

  2. Companion Spirits: If spirits only attach to advanced magicians like one of the Seven Sages, it would explain why “Felix” has Wirdian the White Lizard. It would explain why Cyril & Thornley, who are lower-ranked magicians, don’t have companion spirits. And it would explain why “Felix” is always calm and seems distant and hiding things. 「人当たりの良い柔らかな笑顔の下に、何か悍ましいものが蠢いているようなー」Because he’s not the real Felix! And the fake “Felix” knows Monica is a Seven Sages and is toying with her – even going so far as to braid her hair, etc. Very sinister twist to the hair styling scene! And maybe “Felix” sneaks out at night to go somewhere because he’s actually visiting the real Felix, who he has imprisoned somewhere else??

  3. The Chess Piece scene: I recall an earlier scene where “Felix” is in his dorm room playing with a chess piece when he is talking to his companion spirit Wirdian, about Monica and why he wanted her on the student council and kept close by. It’s like he has some plans for her? Also, the night Cyril had his magic power poisoning episode in the forest, both Monica’s group and Felix (with Wirdian) set off in the direction of the forest around the same time. Monica’s time spent with Cyril seemed to take a while. While I was reading this encounter, I was half-expecting Felix to come out of the shadows and reveal himself to the reader and/or to Monica’s group. But instead Nero, encounters Felix right next to the dorm, (pretending to be?) fixing the plank covering the gap in the dorm fence. When Nero introduces himself as Dustin Gunter and carries on about being a traveler who happened upon Cyril, it felt like “Felix” was just playing along and knew exactly who Nero was. Nero got away too easily, it seemed.

  4. The blue sapphire brooch gift: Louis made the brooch. The brooch had a GPS-like tracker, in that the ruby brooch Louis kept would always know where the sapphire Brooch was located (i think that’s what was written). The King gave the brooch to his son as a present. “Felix” knew that’s what it was (although no one would suspect this knowledge because Felix was known as a 素人 at magic) and ordered Wirdian to crush it.

    Now Felix wasn’t protected by the brooch and Louis also couldn’t see where Felix was. The broken brooch is what led Louis to ask Monica to go under cover at Selendia Academy. From “Felix’s” perspective, it seemed from the start, he knew what the brooch was and knew it could track him (whether he knew it was his father the King or Louis that was tracking him is unclear…). “Felix” might not want to be tracked because he needed to sneak away from the boys’ dorm to go… :thinking:? Also (and this is a stretch…more stretchy than this whole theory … was his whole plan from the beginning was to set up Louis so that Louis would send Monica to Selendia and right into his grasp…!).

  5. The “blue-eyed man” in the prologue: At the end of the prologue the lurker is described as 男の青い目に映るのは、この静かで美しい魔術を行使した魔女の姿。ほうっと簡単の吐息を漏らし、男は小さく呟く。「やっと見つけた。。。僕が、夢中になれるもの」その声はまるで恋に落ちたかのように、熱を帯びていた。I definitely thought this was Felix. Or “Felix”. The only thing that gave me pause was the eyes are described as blue, which seems intentional. Throughout the book, the second prince is always described as having blue eyes with a hint of green. So, this discrepancy makes it a little unclear as to who the mystery shadow man is. This character sees Monica in action and admiringly says to himself that he finally found something he could be crazy about, sounding as though he had fallen in love. BUT! What if this is “Felix” who possesses a malevolent passion in Monica for her powers? I feel like that description left some room for an alternate interpretation other than the case of a young prince innocently swooning for the Silent Witch. Note the end of the book, the words describing Felix as he talks about the Silent Witch are mirrored with the prologue: 「。。。千年に一人の天才魔術師。。。」 語る声は次第に熱を帯び、端整な白い横顔はほんのりと朱に染まる。まるで愛しい人を語るかのようにうっとりと、フェリックスはその名を口にした。「<沈黙の魔女>レディ・いーエヴァレット」

  6. Is Emmanuel Darwin “Felix”?? – Cyril wore a protective magic brooch that was supposed to prevent excess magic power from poisoning him. The protective power of the brooch was tampered with around the same time that Cyril discovered Thornley’s involvement in the student council embezzlement with Aaron O’Brien. The result of the tampering was that Cyril was absorbing the magic power rather than emitting it, causing magic poisoning. Monica discovers the brooch had a Seven Sages name carved on the back – Emmanuel Darwin. She mentions that Louis described Darwin as a money-hungry villain.

    What if the connection between Cyril Ashley, Student Council VP and Emmanuel Darwin is that “Felix” is actually Darwin disguised as Felix? Perhaps Cyril (who is attached to Felix at the hip and fiercely loyal to him) is learning magic through Darwin/Felix and Darwin/Felix gave him the protective brooch?? The real Felix is described as being trusted by noble families within and abroad due to his diplomatic skills. If Darwin were to impersonate anyone with far-reaching influence and possibly the next in line to the King, Felix would be the person to choose. Perhaps money-hungry Seven Sages Emmanuel Darwin is the figure in the prologue admiring Monica because he has some plan to use her to get rich??

  7. The embezzlement by Thornley and Aaron O’Brien - was this all “Felix’s” idea? -About Duke Crockford. “Felix” noted that it was Crockford who controls Selendia Academy, who hired Thornley and who ordered that Aaron O’Brien be named Student Council Treasurer. For these reasons, it would be difficult to lay complete blame on Felix for what happened. But, what if “Felix” was somehow behind the embezzlement, inducing Thornley subtly into committing the crime with his co-conspirator. The idea being to get rid of them and to replace O’Brien with Monica…and what about “Felix’s” complaint about Louis sniffing around Felix and discovering the embezzlement crime, arresting Thornley and take away “Felix’s” spoils? 「そろそろ尻尾を出す頃だと思っていたのだけど、獲物を横取りされたようだ」whaat tail?

Thank you for attending my conspiracy lecture.

PS. Agree with the others about everybody’s treatment of Monica. They all need to step back and stop projecting on her. What’s with all these insecure people saying Monica needs to be more this or that, less this or that - appearance, clothing, behavior, manners etc. She never criticizes anyone and she even felt bad for overdoing it with the pigs and Thornley. No wonder she retreated to the mountain hut. :sweat_smile:

What a fun book to read! Thank you to Redglare for hosting and suggesting the book. As always, I am so thankful to have discovered this IBC. It took me a couple of years of doing Wanikani review before I ventured into the community forum of Wanikani, but what a supportive community this is. Although I fell behind in the weekly readings for 沈黙の魔女, I looked forward to catching up on all the comments everyone made for each week.

And, I am also excited to have finished my second book in Japanese!

5 Likes

@TobiasW, congratulations on your first IBC!

Politics

Well, most of it isn’t completely new but has been alluded to before, but it got a lot clearer and more reliable since now we’re hearing it from people directly involved. For example, the much-mentioned Duke Crockford is trying to use Felix as a figurehead for their political faction, but Felix himself feels ill-treated by him, judging by his complaints that his grandfather always blames him when things go wrong. He also hates to be seen as a mere puppet. He seems to want out from under his grandfather’s thumb and do his own thing (whatever that is, and whatever part the Silent Witch plays in his plans).

If Louis understands the king’s order correctly, the king himself wants to put his own son under constant supervision by a reliable member of the Seven Sages who is not his ally. The most obvious explanation is that the king is afraid that Crockford is going to try a grab for the crown and then use Felix as his puppet king, and he wants to know if Felix is a willing collaborator. That’s why he gave the job to a member of another faction, but also phrased it as an order to guard Felix, to make it clear that he doesn’t want him to be harmed.

Also, this made me curious about the first prince. Louis thinks of Felix as a vapid pretty boy who might have a sinister hidden agenda. That tells us that Louis isn’t easily impressed by good looks and charm alone. So, what did the first prince do to impress Louis enough to join his faction? Is he ugly but actually really politically savvy?

3 Likes
Replies

Hm, I share @TobiasW’s opinion that Felix is the one from the prologue 100%. To be fair, it wasn’t stated clearly, but I would be really surprized if it wasn’t him :slight_smile:

This is the quote that makes me think that he still doesn’t realize the Silent Witch’s identity:

あぁ、どうせ七賢人を監視役に仕向けるなら、〈結界の魔術師〉より、あの人にしてくれればいいのに

Why would he said that in this regretful manner if he knew that it had actually happened already.

5 Likes
reply

that’s a good point いいのに meaning Felix is not yet aware that Monica is the Silent Witch. I somehow missed that important nuance.

1 Like
Replies

Ok, you convinced me.

I wish I’d taken more notes, it already feels like I read this ages ago. But I remember a little about this part. I was confused as well, but eventually concluded that Felix was on the verge of exposing Thornley himself, possibly to use the case against his grandfather in some way(?), but now Louis got the credit. I suppose the tail part was some sort of metaphor for him seeing himself as an animal that hunts prey.

3 Likes

Thanks! :heart:

Reply

We can only speculate, but considering that Felix seemed bored out of his mind and desperate to get some more fun things in before he might be headed for a life in a golden cage, I think his primary motivation might be that he enjoys outmaneuvering scheming opponents (i.e. Thornley).

(Also I’m not convinced that he has any ill will against his grandfather.)

5 Likes
Reply

尻尾を出す is an expression :3


Edit: Btw, it’s fun to read everyone’s theories. I’m currently reading book 9 the latest volume and I know too much to reply safely on specific scenes :laughing:

4 Likes

Oh, but then you can tell us how far along volume 9 is compared to the WN, and how many volumes you think there might still be. I spent a fair amount of time trying to find out, without any proper results…

4 Likes

Interesting expression! I believe the origin of the English expression of “showing our true colors”came from pirate ships or smugglers sailing under a false flag to deceive others.

I wonder what the origin is for 尻尾を出す. Perhaps a suspicion that among us humans are other entities disguising themselves as human (eg きつね🦊) …

3 Likes

Looking at the web novel chapters, I suspect volume 9 will be the last one. I actually doubt there will be one more. I’ll probably have a definite answer after I finish reading it. I’ll get back to you when I know more!

ohh, insteresting! :eyes:

Sounds about right! This was in the screenshot in my previous post:

〔化けていたキツネやタヌキが尻尾を出して正体を見破られる意から〕

5 Likes

I missed that part of your reply. なるほど!

2 Likes

Embarassingly, I didn’t realise that was what that katakana name was meant to be, despite knowing several O’Briens IRL.

Anyway, I don’t have too much to say on the plot, since I was behind for so much of it and over such a long period of reading, it’s been hard for me to maintain a coherent thought on it. Especially from like 50% to 80% of the way through, it was kind of a slog but it got better near the end from the Cyril chapter onwards.

5 Likes

Well. I made it to the end :sweat_smile:

To be honest, it’s definitely not the sort of book I’d have read natively. But it was fun enough to read in Japanese. Even if the katakana names slowly wore me down into the ground; and the mad twists kept me second guessing if I’d just misread something.

Anyway- roll on the next.

And the commentary - it’s always appreciated :slight_smile:

6 Likes