Particle cluster of ... fun

Okay, so here’s a sentence- the first time I read it a couple weeks ago I understood what was going on, but going over it, for some reason I have no clue what’s going on with a particular cluster of particles.


The translation is written as “Although he’s saying he doesn’t have time due to homework, I heard he went on a date with Miki-chan.”

That’s fine, I get the general sense of what the sentence was intended to mean, but… here’s my problem.


How? So the つ is the slang for “という”, but I don’t see how と言ってんのに works. If the use of “のに” was already intended, why would という be conjugated to て form? Shouldn’t it just be つんのに?

Maybe I’m just having a huge brain fart because it made sense to me before, but right now I just cannot get over how this could make sense. If somebody else has answered this question in another thread, just link me and I’ll delete this-I didn’t seem to find anything when I searched the forums.

Oh, and while I’m at it in regards to という, a friend of mine who translates Japanese told me that the difference between というのは and のは was that the use of という is MORE formal, even though it’s more subject to slang than のは? Just want to get a confirmation from other sources to make sure I got that right, cuz it… doesn’t sound right to me.

I think つってん = と言ってる

And yes, というのは is more formal than just のは , but that’s a different thing, it doesn’t mean “to say”

@Lorentso, yes I’m aware the differences in the two uses for という, but thanks for clarifying just in case! More formal, huh… that’s really weird.

On といってる, I’m pretty sure the ん is the shortened explanatory の, right? So wouldn’t it be といってるん?

And, now that I think about it, what purpose does the に serve in this again? Shouldn’t the two sentences be tied with が instead? Since the purpose is to say “Despite his claim to be doing homework”? What exactly is に targeting? I feel like this might also be another brain fart, because it seemed to make sense beforehand.

And lastly, can you really have an explanatory の and a nominalizing の one after the other? といっているののに. … ?

〜のに means although 〜

ん can be の but in this case is る
it happens before an N-sound, eg わかんない = わからない

(another example here:
“in the phrase どうなってんの , ん is a less-polite contraction of いる”)

1 Like

Just to be agree with what’s here in standard Japanese, if you see てん it’s virtually always てる

Okay, I’m an idiot. I knew there was a reason I understood it before =P

I completely forgot のに has a binary function, I was piecing all the particles the wrong way. のに was on me, I forgot. However, the ている shortened to てん is on Tae Kim! He mentions the idea of it as a passing notion once, and then doesn’t mention it again until he used it in that example sentence. What a turd ;u;

From now I’ll likely think of this mix up to remember のに, and likely the same for てん. Thanks to both of you for helping! Soon I’ll have things a little more cemented, and I’ll start spamming Lang-8 with 日記 entries, hahahaha.

Does anyone use the forums here for the same purpose as Lang-8? I don’t know how they’d do it but it doesn’t seem too far fetched.

You can check out the Japanese only section.

Oh, is it used similarly to Lang-8?

Eh… It allows you to post and converse in Japanese. And Mami-San helps out in that section. Lang8 is nice, but unless you already have an amount, they recently stopped accepting new registrations.

These forums are dedicated for the community helping out in questions and practice you may need in Japanese.

Well… as long as you stay away from campfire. :sweat_smile:

Oho! Luckily I’ve had an account for years (こういち先生 suggests to make one in textfugu, which I completed back in 2015). However, I think it’d be nicer to study in the community. I like the people here =P

まみさん? だれ? And what’s wrong with Campfire? =P

This is our まみさん here:

Also, campfire is the place to go when you want to hide from the world. Nothing wrong with it. :blush: It’s been referred to as the water cooler section of the forums. We talk about Japanese things, but not much about Japanese language questions.

ああ、そうですね? じゃ、ありがとう!


(Yes, that’s a sentence Discourse.)

This topic was automatically closed 365 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.