Master List of Book Clubs

So we’re happy with this format?

Title Status Natively
Level
本好きの下剋上 Offshoot ongoing 32
雪国 Completed 47
容疑者Xの献身 Completed 33
すべてがFになる Offshoot ongoing 32
人間失格 Completed 40

And for ABBC and BBC (and IBC?) we’ll do this:

Title Status Natively
Level
本好きの下剋上
ENGLISH TITLE
Offshoot ongoing 32
雪国
Snow Country
Completed 47

What do we do about rereads? Use < br /> and have a both completed status and a Reread ongoing/completed? This is what that would look like:

Title Status Natively
Level
本好きの下剋上
ENGLISH TITLE
Offshoot ongoing 32
雪国
Snow Country
Completed
(fake) Reread completed
47

On that note: I’m still curious what other people’s opinion of where the slow read of コンビニ人間 should fall. I’m honestly not sure if it count as a reread for IBC. I’d be fine with adding it to the misc scheduled section, but at the same time, it would lose the link to IBC and how it is supposed to help bridge the gap.


Also about the offshoot for 本好き, I didn't put a link on the offshoot part because when I looked at the club, it seemed to use the original ABC home thread as the home thread for the whole series. The link added for the offshoot is instead to the volume 4+ discussion thread (which means volume 2 and 3 is kinda skipped). Every other offshoot I linked to had a different home thread for the offshoot part.

I feel like we need to decide what to do here so we do the same thing across all clubs; I’m pretty sure some of the other clubs have used the original home thread as the series home thread. If an offshoot club doesn’t use a different home thread but continues to use the one for the first volume read with the main club, do we link the offshoot part in the status category, and if so to what thread? (Home thread, first discussion thread for the offshoot, volume (home) thread if such exists)

To me, it is weird to link to a discussion thread since they typically have less info. And while I think it is redundant to link to the home thread again, it would make all offshoots look the same (and make it easier to pick what to link, if it is always the home thread for the series whether it is separate from the first volume or not).


We should also consider adding a small explanation what Natively is, so people understand what that level thing is. :slight_smile: (I wouldn’t be a good pick for that because I don’t use Natively so someone else can probably explain that better and more concisely. I’m also not known for being concise. xD)

7 Likes