How is that answer incorrect? Or have I lost my marbles

Hey thanks! I didn’t know about that one.

3 Likes

Glad to be of help!

I hope you stick around.

1 Like

Just so you know, it is commonly misunderstood that doing well at school (‘intelligence’) and learning a language are traits fluent learners have, but that’s not true. Learning languages have more to do with thinking differently (i.e., thinking outside the box of one’s own languages, understanding the culture, etc.) and using the language.

I had the concern about learning more kanji down the line. I think WK does a good job at breaking down and reviewing the kanji so that it becomes easier to distinguish similar looking kanji. Over time, the one’s you used to struggle with won’t be so bad anymore. From time to time, I make mistakes, but for the most part I can tell the differences between similar ones. Again that comes with practice (e.g., reading and writing).

3 Likes

I would not recommend WK for someone who struggles with English. Have a look at how the radicals are done and then substitute you own language to do the stories. It is counterproductive to try and master one language in order to begin another. I also don’t see Kanji as being the best place to start learning Japanese, since there are simple grammar lessons available on YouTube in a variety of languages.
What is your home language?

I’ll definitely stay for now. :blush:
I just hope that life won’t get in my way.

Your reply cheered me up a bit!
My biggest issue right now is simply not noticing the small differences between characters when I’m reviewing them.

For instance, 右 and 石 are almost identical (for me at least). When I slowly deconstruct them into radicals it’s not a big deal - one has a narwhal radical and the other is a stone radical (which looks like leaf+mouth), and then I remember that “leaves are not supposed to grow on a stone”, thus 石 means stone. Bless the radicals and mnemonics :crabigator:

But when I’m getting ahead of myself, I start rushing through the reviews, and then I stop noticing the small details and it results in wrong answers.
Hell, I even mistook 月 for 日 several times when I was in a hurry :sweat_smile:
I also hate the 午, 生, 矢 and 天 :sob:

But all in all, maybe it’s for the better that all these kanji fall back into Apprentice1? This way I can review them more. Maybe one day I’ll be able to distinguish them quickly.

Also by practise, do you mean handwriting? Like in a notebook? I’ve read somewhere that it’s not an effective way to learn kanji :thinking:

Studying in English is extra work, that’s painfully true.
But on the other hand, as others stated, it’s worth a try. I also browsed through the old threads and it turns out that there are quite a few non-natives here! Seeing mid- and high- level people from my country is pretty encouraging.

I always postponed studying Japanese (like, for 7 years or more??) and constantly deceived myself that “I’m studying the language because I watch tons of anime”.

If by ‘simple grammar lessons’ you mean things like how to introduce yourself and what’s the basic sentence structure, then rest assured, I have those things nailed. Also, I firmly believe that Youtube won’t teach me anything useful/long-term. If I, myself, won’t be the one doing the work, then I’ll forget stuff shortly after I close the video.

Just a week ago, I knew ZERO kanji. I want to properly study Japanese so I need a reliable tool to learn them, and truthfully, the English resources seem better compared to those in my language. WK is one of the things I’ve recently started using.

//That doesn’t change the fact that I’m sitting with the dictionary open in the other tab//
I’m a lil’ jelly of you, native English speakers.

2 Likes

I have a notebook in which I write out the grammar lessons that the youtube videos at nihongonomori give me… Which makes a 7 minute video take me at least 20 minutes to watch! XD

It certainly helps me, but it’s important to know that everyone has their own learning styles. Once you’ve found yours, keep at it. There are many different ways to study and memorize and practice things. Do you know what kind of learner you are?

Video? Audio? Physical (you have to do it)? A combination (audio-visual?)?
I know some people who cannot learn things unless they figure it out for themselves or work it out for themselves. Some people need music/a song. When you learn these things about yourself, you will learn better.

I hope that helps!

2 Likes

Not going to post anything helpful as it been debated above…

But you missed a perfect opportunity. You should have titled this pose:
How is that answer incorrect? Or have I lost my marbles.

Tbh, good eye, When i reviewed this item, I didn’t even notice at all - just filled without thinking. Maybe I lost a few marbles.

3 Likes

Dont worry your not the only one. Even though I do reviews daily it still takes me about 15-20 days to level up. Learning a new language is pretty hard, why most people don’t even try. I have many friends who watch anime and most them don’t even care enough to try learning Japanese because they know it will be difficult.

I have gotten some like 力 九 and others mixed up all the time. It wont be easy but will be worth it, will get many answers wrong and will forget things but just dont give up. Wanikani is for sure the best resource for learning kanji and works well with other resources. Knowing the kanji will make learning grammar and vocab a lot easier.

Edit: also dont forget to use other resources to improve your Japanese. I cant list them all here but there are other topics talking about them. Things like memrise, anki, lingodeer, bunpro, Genki, Japanese from zero.
While wanikani will teach you vocab its main purpose is just teaching kanji, to really learn Japanese will need other resources too.
Wish the best of luck

2 Likes

That’s interesting. I guess I’ll have to try out those methods and then evaluate which works for me. Whatever the case may be, I think that it all comes down to being pressured/motivated to learn something. I finally have a reason to speak Japanese so I’m more serious about it than I have ever been. So no matter which method I’ll decide on, I’m going to do my best!

Oh my. I didn’t know abouy this idiom before, such a shame. But the opportunity is not yet lost! //secretly changes the title//

5 Likes

I have been looking for that magic method!

1 Like

I once thought that the language in anime is exactly the same as the actual Japanese, and man, was I wrong. And I actually have the Genki textbook but I haven’t done a single chapter yet >…> I thought I should learn some kanji first so I wouldn’t feel as overwhelmed.
Let’s cheer on each other on our way to fluency :sparkles::sparkles: (however long it’ll take)

2 Likes

Maybe not. But it should be pretty obvious that @tododoki doesn’t really have any problems with English, and any efforts to convince us otherwise can be attributed to modesty. :wink:

3 Likes

It’s just that my self-esteem is as high as me.
And I’m rather short

2 Likes

By “practice” I mean reading AND writing.

Writing doesn’t necessarily only mean handwriting, but handwriting is known to be effective for remembering and distinguishing one similar kanji from another. Practicing handwriting alongside with WK will slow the process down quite a bit because there’s more to learn at once, but if speed is not an issue and learning the forms is your priority, then that’s something to consider. If you choose to practice handwriting, you can get a physical notebook to write or you can practice on a smart phone or a tablet through apps.

FULL DISCLOSURE: I didn’t practice handwriting while going through the levels on WK, but I did write in Japanese to friends online. Doing message exchanges got me acquainted with certain kanji quickly because I had to both read and compose messages on a regular basis. When I did start practicing handwriting, I didn’t practice forms out of context (for example, repeating the same kanji 200 times in a notebook, etc.). Instead, when reviewing grammar I’ve studied before, I just copy the Japanese from the textbook I’m using and write it down as I review the material. I’ve memorized quite a bit from that repetition. Of course I need to branch out to other resources to practice different kinds of kanji, but it’s been effective for me at the moment.

But over time, some of the kanji you’re having trouble with now will probably cease being a problem after numerous reviews on WK. The key is consistency.

2 Likes

Maybe you heard that it’s not “efficient.” Because it’s basically how Japanese people learn new kanji, and it takes them 9 years to learn roughly the same amount of kanji that we at WK learn.

It’s effective, because they end up being more deeply ingrained, but you can’t rush if you do it their way.

2 Likes

Texting with Japanese folks seems like a good idea but I think it’s too soon for me :sweat_smile: I’m going to start writing sentences with context like you recommended - and I’ll see how it goes.

I don’t think I’ll ever need to handwrite anything in Japanese… But for the sake of better memorization, I’ll try to include some practise in my study routine!

Thank you both for the advice <3

1 Like

What are the “reading” items asking for, exactly? I had assumed that “reading” meant “represent, in hiragana, how this word should be pronounced when spoken (i.e., how it should be read aloud).” But that can’t be right, because certain ways of representing the correct pronunciation (such as the OP’s example) are nevertheless considered incorrect “readings.”

So does “reading” actually just mean “spell these words using kana instead of kanji”?

That’s one way to resurrect a thread :thinking:

2 Likes

The last post was only six days ago! I can’t be checkin’ this forum every dang minute, I’m a busy guy…:sunglasses:

1 Like

Absolutely understandable :joy:
Regarding your question, I guess WK wants the reading that’s written correctly. This particular word is accepted in hiragana (with a katakana’s dash) only out of convenience.

1 Like