Books that show how handwritten characters look without the flourishes/print fonts?

There are some with alternative forms

2 Likes

Where is the one on the right used? In printed books or do some people handwrite that way too?

The second book series I linked to is a reputable publisher (Tuttlle) so you can also try them. Obviously the order of kanji is different and they also have the brush font (it’s really hard to get away from that one as they are always mimicking the calligraphy style. Even native content will do this).

Also, you can try getting a kanji source that shows stroke order and then a kanji practice notebook (literally they are just blank notebooks with squares) to write alongside them.

There was also someone here who was making printable practice sheets in WK order for those who wanted to practice writing. Currently the site doesn’t load for me… maybe it’s just me though: https://kanji.sh/write?utm_source=kanji-printer

Yeah I’ve seen it on printed books. Personally, I also tend to write it that way. It’s just personal preference.

1 Like

I had a teacher who wrote similarly to the one on the right (and I do as well as a result).

1 Like

I’m not 100% about how they teach handwriting in Japan, but as a Chinese speaker, here’s the thing: kanji were traditionally written with brushes, and even how they’re written with pens and pencils today is supposed to emulate that. For that matter, apparently a big reason for why chalkboards are still popular in the three nations of the ‘Sinogram sphere’ (aka Japan, China and Korea, the three main nations where Chinese characters were historically used) is that calligraphy shows up better on chalkboards. That is, when teaching students, teachers can show students how to write beautifully: where to apply more pressure, where to apply less pressure, where strokes should be thicker and so on. In other words, very often, it is from brushstroke-style kanji that most natives learn. My primary school Chinese handwriting practice books were full of those. As natives or descendants of native kanji users, we’re expected to try to recreate the brushstroke aesthetic with our pens and pencils. Even kana books for Japanese primary school kids include variations in stroke thickness that are inherent in that aesthetic, despite the fact that the strokes are so thin relative to their length that they’re clearly meant to be written with pens or pencils:

I agree from personal experience that having realistic pen writing to imitate makes things easier, because many brushstroke fonts are unrealistically ideal, but the main factor that allows one to improve one’s handwriting is explanation of concepts and techniques. I know that that isn’t quite your goal as a kanji learner, but that’s what the best calligraphy books provide. Basic handwriting practice books meant for first-time learners (e.g. primary school children) usually just settle for ingraining the brushstroke model into everyone’s mind as the ideal to aim for. (If you need proof of my calligraphy experience… look at my profile picture. I wrote it myself.)

The general rule is this: if you’re looking at a brushstroke font that is non-cursive (i.e. there’s no sign of any threads of ink linking strokes, and all the angles are nice and regular), then everything you see is an integral part of the kanji. If you want to know what the minimum recognisable form of the kanji would be, then mentally remove all line thickness variation. That’s the answer.

I took a quick look at kanji practice books meant for primary school children, and I came up with these two that I think you might find more palatable (the rest were pretty run of the mill and show stroke order with numbering alone):

This one uses brushstroke-type models, but it’s packed full of information on kanji usage and has diagrams of kanji evolution from Oracle Bone Script to modern script. It also includes stroke order information and occasional comments on things to look out for when writing these kanji by hand. I think it’s excellent for someone who’s studying kanji. The text may be difficult for you to read at this stage, but there’s furigana everywhere and with time, you might be able to use it for reading practice if you want to learn more about the usage and history of kanji. This book is probably also closer to being ‘WaniKani style’ because it goes kanji by kanji and aims to teach the reader about how to write each kanji as part of a kanji learning programme. There’s no space for tracing inside the book, but frankly, even though it’s true that tracing is an ancient and traditional form of calligraphy training, the only way to really get better is to write kanji while attempting to imitate the model yourself, constantly asking yourself why the model looks that way, and why your kanji don’t look like the model. You can just as easily trace over the printed kanji using a ‘sheathed’ ballpoint pen for practice. It works for learning stroke order, believe me.

This one is a genuine calligraphy course for primary school students. I can’t accurately describe it any other way. The author includes instructions on alignment and exercises for the basic strokes and movements. There’s also a brief section at the beginning with hiragana and katakana models. Primary school kanji are the focus of this course, but there are no promises on the number of kanji that will be covered, and the book is not structured like a kanji dictionary as with the first book, but as a series of kanji grouped by the calligraphy concepts that they train. This book will teach you how to write well (if you get through the instructions), and all the models are handwritten with a pen. However, since it’s purely handwriting-focused, it contains no kanji data other than kun’yomi, on’yomi and stroke order, and is certainly not ordered ‘WK style’ (i.e. like a reference book that’s mean to teach kanji).

Finally, you might want to look at the ペン文字 stuff on Amazon.jp, and possibly add the words 練習帳 (‘exercise book’) to make it clear that you’re looking for a kanji practice book.

Between the two books I linked to, I’d recommend the second one if good handwriting with ‘pen stroke’ models for reference is your focus. On the other hand, if you’re willing to accept brushstroke models again (but ones that are relatively plain) while getting lots of kanji information and seeing how kanji evolved, then I’d recommend the first. Take a look at both of them. I hope one of them is what you’re looking for.

EDIT: Oops. In hindsight, I guess the English-language books proposed by @chantellis are more appropriate, but since you mentioned ‘Amazon Japan’, I figured you might want ‘helpful models’ and diagrams even if you couldn’t read much of the text (for now, I mean), so I kinda dived right in. I didn’t think to check if there were English-language books on kanji (whereas of course, there are).

9 Likes

Stumbled on that channel myself and it’s very satisfying for the eyes.

Just ran through the thread again to see what I missed while searching for those books, and I figured I’d respond to a few things.

I covered what likely happens in classrooms just now, and I know for a fact that in China, teachers use the brushstroke style on the blackboard to teach students how to write. (I’m not from China; I’m from Singapore. I’ve seen videos though.) However, it’s not just limited to classrooms: all the people who provide handwritten models for writing base them on the brushstroke aesthetic, albeit usually a simplified one, which is the style that’s preferred in Japan. (The style common in China is often full of flourishes, but really messy and hard to read unless you know the cursive calligraphy and abbreviations used in China.) The people who are considered to have the best handwriting also write in imitation of the brushstroke style. Here are some examples:


from a book on how to write beautifully with a pen and

from a handwriting improvement book aimed at adults and

from Kayo-sensei, a Japanese calligrapher on Twitter who tweets in English (@kayoshodo).

Everyone is taught to write in the brushstroke style in everyday life. It’s just that not everyone masters it (I had to learn it myself from a calligraphy book after graduating), and factors like the need to rush during note-taking in high school or university leads to deformation and bad habits that make the brushstroke look disappear. I’d also argue that the reason brushstroke-style kana don’t appear in manga is because more and more manga is digitised, and calligraphy shows up poorly on tablets without pressure-sensitive styluses, and not because no mangaka uses the brushstroke-style. (Many of them have very neat handwriting anyhow.) Thus, in other words,

Exactly. The brushstroke style is the current ideal model and probably always will be.

The left-hand version is actually just a linked-up form of the right-hand version. It’s the result of making a very shallow丶that links cursively to short 丿on the right. It’s just that the cursive links can’t be reflected in a clean font like the one @plantron’s example used. That’s why the two seem completely unrelated. Watch the video in this thread starting at 0:47 to see how that happened starting from the source kanji (曽), which also has those two little strokes. Here’s an intermediate version, which is how I write そ:


You can see that I start with a short diagonal stroke, stop, and cursively connect to the next stroke.

4 Likes

The Kanji workbook for Tobira does have “handwritten” styles for the kanji it covers. It is not a workbook in the same way as the others I’ve linked though (it doesn’t give you space to write the character out for example).

That’s interesting. I wasn’t expecting that.

By the way, @virileboy, another place you can look at for examples (even if the kanji there aren’t necessarily all going to be useful for you) is in the Jōyō Kanji List. Take a look: https://www.bunka.go.jp/kokugo_nihongo/sisaku/joho/joho/kijun/naikaku/pdf/joyokanjihyo_20101130.pdf
Starting from page 7, you have a whole list of kanji meant to illustrate the presence of multiple equally valid styles and possibilities in handwriting, including kanji that don’t look like the standard Ming Dynasty Script used in Japanese typography, and they’re all written using a pen.

In my experience, this is true of Japan as well. I remember teachers using the chalk as if it was a brush (moving their arm in a flowing fashion and using the side of the chalk for emphasis, etc.). Kanji stroke order actually is easier to remember that way and the “flow” of the character helps with proportion as well. That may not be how every teacher teaches, but it’s how several of mine did (in US college classes as well, not just elementary school).

I’m not really sure that the type of book you are looking for actually exists at present, though it would be cool if it did!

1 Like

I use ‘flow’ to help me remember stroke order and visualise characters, and actually, the sometimes confusing ‘threads’ we see between strokes are just the result of stroke order being followed when going faster.

Are you talking about what I said here:

? Because I’m not sure exactly what you’re referring to. Sorry. :stuck_out_tongue:

1 Like

It was to the OP. I meant I don’t think there is a book with lots of actual handwriting samples and such. I’m not sure that’s actually what OP is after, or just my interpretation though.

Ah, OK, I had that impression, but since it was also a reply to my post…

I think the link you posted to that N4 book is the closest one can get in English, though I honestly feel that the handwriting samples provided are too much like Jisho animations. They’re neat, tidy and well proportioned, but don’t feel like what a native would be taught as a model. They’re a bit ‘lifeless’ if you ask me.

In Japanese though, books containing actual handwriting samples or styles that can be imitated easily with a pen exist. I’ve already posted several examples from courses for adults that can be easily found on Amazon by searching ペン文字, and in particular, this course (found by searching 小学 漢字 練習帳=‘primary school kanji exercise book’)

contains 手本 (models for imitation) that were written by hand by the author himself. The Twitter calligrapher I mentioned (@kayoshodo) also publishes her own books, which may very well contain such samples.

My understanding is that it’s traditionally quite common to use samples of a master calligrapher’s work as a model for calligraphy practice, and with modern printing techniques, it’s become even easier to buy copies of such models. Such books exist in Chinese as well, and in fact, the calligraphy course I used to learn to write well, which I ordered from China, was filled with the fountain pen calligraphy of 田英章, a well-known Chinese calligrapher.

In short, such books do exist, and are in fact very common, but you’ll have to buy them in Japanese or in Chinese. The diagrams of kanji inside should already be quite instructive, because there are usually lines to highlight proportions, general shapes or important features, but to fully benefit, one has to be able to read the instructions and explanations. That’s the sort of book I was talking about when I said

because real calligraphy books use the author’s work or analyse famous historical works and comment on them. Computerised fonts, no matter how beautiful, aren’t sufficient for calligraphy teaching.

3 Likes

I was only thinking of English, but you’re right. That looks perfect (sorry, I didn’t look at it closely before).

1 Like

It’s OK. My post was long and potentially tiring to read. :stuck_out_tongue: Details tend to get lost in such posts.

1 Like

I found this book while I was studying in London and wanted to practise writing Japanese. I don’t know if this is what you’re looking for.

1 Like

It doesn’t load for me either but the Skritter app has a wanikani deck to practice writing but it does have errors sometimes like some characters are taught in print font form not handwritten.

Already had the 2nd book in my Amazon Japan cart :grin:. Took me hours & hours of translating each book description few weeks ago to end up with discovering the calligraphy guy. This is the kind of stuff I’m looking for, cause explanations are never there in the English books.

Do you mind showing a dragram of the ink threads in a stroke that are not critical? Not sure I get it.

1 Like

i have no issue with brushstroke but the lack of instruction on how to physically move the writing utensil to create the character is irritating. English books don’t even talk about stroke ends which is why so far I have only bought Japanese writing books.

1 Like