🐈 にゃんにゃん探偵団 🕵️‍♀️ Kitty Detectives 2 Home Thread!

This post constitutes proof of life. :stuck_out_tongue_closed_eyes:

My decision to read both KD2 and Flying Witch was nuts. I thought Flying Witch would be easier because it was manga, but after beating my head against the gender-driven local dialect for what seemed like 1,000 pages, I realized I was in over my head and that was it. :no_good_woman:t2:

Unfortunately, by that time I was well behind with KD2 and the busy season at work did not help. The book club thread became a spoiler minefield for me so I stopped participating. :slightly_frowning_face: I hope to get back in the swing of things for story three. :crossed_fingers:t2:

7 Likes

If you’re trying to catch up before we start story three but won’t have enough time, I’d recommend skipping story two altogether :slightly_smiling_face:

3 Likes

posting a little early cos I’m with family and may not be able to post later

Story Two… complete! Congrats to everyone who finished it.

This week is our second break, so there’s no discussion thread.

We’ll be starting Story Three on the 30th of December.

If anyone is considering jumping in at this point, please do! The middle story was very short, so there’s still nearly half the book left to read together.

10 Likes

Just in case the description of my new methodology for tackling native material is helpful to someone else in this group, here’s an edited exerpt from my study log:

See you tomorrow for our 3rd case! :nerd_face: :male_detective: :female_detective: :smile_cat:

1 Like

We are BACK for our final story of the book! Buckle up, cos the title is pretty promising…

8 Likes

Oh what do I see, @Micki liked a post in the week 9 discussion thread? Nice to see you here! Are you just lurking or reading along?

3 Likes

Couldn’t resist! Thought I’d join you for the third story! Nice to be back :smiley:

5 Likes

Hi Radish - so sorry I missed your ping, but I’ve been out of state for a while. Seems I have some catching up to do! At least this time I remembered to put WK on vacation mode before I lit out. :grimacing:

edit: first post-return review was not pretty

2 Likes

Not at all! Glad you’re back :blush:

2 Likes

Did we ever discuss Capone’s book ‘recommendations’ on page 68 besides @ChristopherFritz’s reference to Cool Biz? I thought they were great!

I don’t recall anyone else talking about either of the recommendation pages, but will take this opportunity to say if anyone’s skipped over them, give them a browse. His take on Three Little Pigs is great.

From now on, whenever I hear the expression “don’t judge a book by its cover”, I’ll immediately think of Capone.

2 Likes

To be honest, I’d skipped right over them! Will try to take a look tomorrow ^^

2 Likes

Part Two of the last case:

I’ve put it down as being from page 100 to page 108, but the last page is actually part of a double-page spread with a tiny bit of handwritten text on page 109, so feel free to look at that too :stuck_out_tongue:

6 Likes

I was also happy to see Kobutori Jiisan get a look in, although I’m not sure what “ポヨーン” is in Capone’s explanation. There is a cool animated version of this story available on Youtube (from 1929!) The second story on that page is another traditional folk tale - the Tongue Cut Sparrow. I feel the jokes land a little better if you know the original stories. :wink:

You’ll often find onomatopoeia in an adverb-like role, and it’s recognizable by the inclusion of the particle と. For example:

「ほっぺたが ポヨーンと 膨らんでいる」

This と is the quotation marker. His cheek is bulging with a “pyong” sound effect to describe it.

And with that, I now know why I’ve never had any success looking up how と turns certain words into an adverb, no matter how many times I’ve looked it up before. (And I’ve looked it up at least a few times in the past year.) This time I did a web search for “onomatopoeia” and “と” and came across this very informative post that covers it.

3 Likes

Final part of the last case!

Don’t forget to post your theories under a details tag :wink:

7 Likes

Hi everyone!

I’m still stuck somewhere in the second story I’m afraid. My cat sadly passed away a little over a week ago :cry: so for now I’m just trying to slow down my wanikani for a bit to not get swamped. I definitely want to finish the book but I’m going to do it at my own pace :).

5 Likes

Oh, no. I’m sorry to hear that.

2 Likes

My dog passed last month, and I also had a weepy week last week because of it and got behind; self care at times like these is important. Please have an empathy hug from a fellow pet parent :hugs:

4 Likes

Oh I’m so sorry to hear that - sending hugs. It was really good of you to check in with us considering.

1 Like