Extended Mag: Getting into Reading Manga Magazines! šŸ—ž

Blue Period by Tsubasa Yamaguchi

Genres: Coming of Age, Art, Drama, School Life

Triggers: Anxiety

Background on the artist:

Tsubasa Yamaguchi was a unknown mangaka before Blue Period, mainly known for doing the manga adaptation of She and Her Cat, before getting the chance to serialize her first long-term original work, Blue Period, which has been running strong since 2017. It has an anime on Netflix, won the Manga Taisho and the Kodansha Manga Award, and has over 15 million copies sold! A massive massive success for a slice of life manga about a boy who wants to go to art school. A fair amount of the manga is based on her experiences going to Tokyo University of the Arts, the same university that the main character Yatora ends up applying to.

Manga Summary:

The story revolves around Yatora Yaguchi, a high school student who, despite excelling academically, feels unfulfilled and aimless. His life takes a turn when he discovers the world of art and decides to pursue a career as an artist, while he battles guilt and imposter syndrome over his last-minute decision to start making art.

Okay so this is a bit different from what I normally do in this thread. Normally I highlight manga that are hard to find in English, and are lesser known gems that I want to share with you.

Blue Period is not that.

Blue Period is a very successful manga, especially for a monthly seinen magazine like Afternoon, whose works normally don’t breach into the non-Japanese internet. By contrast, aside from Vinland Saga, Blue Period is arguably the most famous manga currently running in Afternoon. There are tons of videos and video essays talking about it from a variety of different angles, so I won’t bore you with my take…

Okay, I lied, just a quick take.

Blue Period to me is the platonic ideal of all coming of age manga. It is beautiful and stressful and uplifting and so much more. I cannot sing its praises enough. It is this perfect mix of artistic exploration and anxiety about finding your place in the world and feeling like you don’t fit in. It talks about the challenges artists face, money, competition, societal expectations, self-doubt, and so much more. The characters are all so realistic and grow and change and don’t always succeed but keep moving forward. I learned more about art reading this manga than any art class I’ve even taken.

I read this right after graduating college and getting my first job, and it felt like the first manga that felt like it really understood what I was going through, even though our experiences were totally different. I don’t think I’m alone in that respect, a lot of people really connect to Yatora’s journey. People who have read Blue Period, what was your experience with it?

But yes, you should really read this manga. That isn’t a take, it’s just a fact.

Sean’s Thoughts/Should You Read This?:

So, I have been reading this manga for years in English, and I just now switched over to Japanese. And honestly, I barely notice the difference! Honestly the biggest slow down is the technical terms and the intricasies of Yatora’s anxieties, but those are mostly just little slow-downs and don’t usually require deep investigations to understand, though that might be because I had so much context from the English version already! :woman_shrugging:

Overall, I would say the experience is basically the same in English and in Japanese!

TLDR:

You shouldn’t read this if:

  • You need action in your stories.
  • You need a confident MC
  • You really really need furigana. You should be fine without it but if you really really really need it then maybe read something else first. but then just read it in English… pretty please…

You should read this if:

  • You are a human
  • Yes that was a serious recommendation. I really do think all people, especially all younger people, should read this manga.
  • I mean you should definitely read it if you like slow burns, character studies, coming of age stories, art, et cetera.
  • But really, you should read it. Its just really good. So do it.

What do you all think? This is probably the most famous manga I’ve covered on this thread so I would love to hear everyone’s thoughts!

Read the first chapter for free here! oh look, no excuse to not give it a try!

10 Likes

Ahhhh, gotcha gotcha. Thanks for the heads up! I think maybe I’ll just make a normal blog (because holy shit Notion seems so complicated I have no idea how you do it @rodan), just for archiving purposes. But I’m definitely staying here because of the great community!!1 :smiling_face_with_three_hearts:

:smiling_face_with_three_hearts: :smiling_face_with_three_hearts:

Oh gosh… I’ve heard about this, old weapons from a more civilized age…

I think I might watch it with my wife first! She just finished Komi and liked it, and maybe it has a similar (though less romantic?) vibe?

AHHHH! That makes so much more sense! Good to know going in!!! Honestly I don’t know anything about it and my cursory glance at the cover got me. I did what everyone elses you not to!

I watched the anime when it came out and absolutely loved it. The music, the animation, the ethereal setting and characters. A great (and short) watch! I was always sad they never made a second season, so now I’ll take things into my own hands haha.

4 Likes

Ha! Genuinely, I haven’t touched any of the formatting or complicated aspects of notion, I just had a spreadsheet and word documents I was keeping privately, and then I added a pages as a ā€˜table’ I think they call it, and I formatted the spreadsheet to import the way I wanted and imported it, and then spent a while adding the entries from the word document in as pages for the table entries. It could probably be much more flashy and efficient if I spent any time at all into formatting or doing interesting things with it!
(But that’s not particularly pressure to go to notion or anything! My use case was a weird one and I’m still not sure there wasn’t a better way to do it so I certianly wouldn’t put it forward as some kind of model!)

4 Likes

Facts.

I read quite a bit of it after the netflix anime came out in english, and really enjoyed this series. I’ll come back to it in japanese someday, but it’s definitely one that hits hardest if you are in certain kinds of life situations. You should read it anyway, regardless of that, because it’s still gorgeous and wonderful, but I will be choosing my reread timing carefully for maximum effect :laughing:

5 Likes

ok you’ve convinced me, firmly on my wishlist with a link to this review to remind me why! Thank you :sparkles:

4 Likes

Well I’ll still take a look at it, but in a month after my job has gotten out of its busy season!

Oooohhh thats a really good point, I didn’t even think of that! I’ve read it through twice now and both times it really hit, but I wasn;t even thinking of any of that!

YAYYYY!!! So glad to hear it! Definitely worth it!!

4 Likes

Catching up on work I should have done a while ago, I’m behind on Grand Jump issues!!!

Grand Jump 2024.3

Interesting One-Shot about two girls, one of whom owns a restaurant! It’s called Kitchen Harrissa, I believe?


Wear the Sky!



A really genki new artist has appeared, and I appreciate her gimmick of dressing like an athletics club member because its the easier to use her whole body because she likes to paint on the floor looking down. It’s a unique idea that’s silly enough to be fun but realistic enough to not be too strange!

Downside is I thought that our MC would have a clever plan to still draw a nude while drawing a self portrait, but nope. It was just kind of a dud.

Fun chapter overall though!

Can We Live Together?


Oh?

AWWWWWWWWWW!!! :sob: :sob: :sob:


AHHHHHHHHHH!!!


AHHHH!H!HH!H!H!H!H!HHH!H!!!HHHHHHH!!!

Here is a picture of my actual notes from the chapter:

Best girl has an amazing chapter and the two of them seem absolutely perfect together!!! I doubt this ship is endgame, but GOD I want it to be. Only downside is I don’t know when we will get a Tsubasa chapter again.

Also, for reference, this is probably the hardest I’ve rooted for a relationship early in a story. I’m not big on staning certain characters (who aren’t from One Piece), but this is an exception (probably because Tsubasa reminds me so much of my wife its crazy haha)

Here are some bonus great expressions from Can We Live Together’s best girl!

Kamo's Negi is Poisoned!

One Outs Reference!

Also, a great chapter/story arc to hope in on, since you did need any background information, and it talks about an important issue, College Education, in a pretty clear way!

Its Diet Time!


Super cute chapter, and setting up Shacho to go back to the gym!

Radiation House was fine, just a side chapter about the newbie being worried about training and stuff. Shrink was alright too, but its topic (drug addiction) is hard to look at given Japan’s thoughts about drugs. Red Mudan was great, an old enemy finds her purpose as Wu Zeitan’s handmaiden.

Zashisu has been out for a while it seems, its coming back in 2024.4 (I checked already), and it seems Torima is over? I wasn’t a fan but I didn’t want it to end so early. Keeping my eyes open for a good new series to start so I can tell y’all about it!

Up next for me is to finish Far East Incident and Harta 76 for Harta, then come back and knock out Grand Jump 2024.4, then I can move on to more Afternoon stuff!

6 Likes

For those who don’t follow the Harta thread but want a manga recommendation, here you are!

4 Likes

Wanted to knock out Grand Jump 2024.4 first, as proof that this is still my main project. I’ll have an Afternoon manga write-up done this week as well, but that will probably be after Harta 76, since I do need to work on that too!

Grand Jump 2024.4

New Stuff:

A new (super short) series! And its by the mangaka of The Strongest Lawyer, a series which I haven’t covered for reasons that will become obvious the second you look at the new series.


Oh, its just because his art is uglier than sin.

Oh, you think I’m joking. You might be looking at those pictures and thinking, come on Sean its not so bad. You misunderstand, those are the best two pictures I could take in the entire chapter. I couldn’t put the worst of it in here as they are more risque (and just fucking awful) than what I like to post.

Do you know what kills me though? This is a BODYSWAP STORY!



Why does that piss me off? Well, I actually really love bodyswap and genderswap stories. For example, my favorite manga for most of my life has been Ranma 1/2, which I unabashedly love. In general I think these stories can really really fun and the premise usually has so much potential for interesting storytelling. I know that a lot of them are bad, and by their nature they are all quite problematic, but they are a guilty pleasure of mine, and so I’m always on the lookout for good new genderswap/bodyswap stories (and if you know any good ones please let me know!). But I also understand for some people they can be triggering, and that they aren’t everyone’s cup of tea! I like stories with interesting explorations of gender that ask interesting questions, or are at least have some good-natured charm like Ranma or Your Name.

This has none of that. This is the lowest common denominator of body swap stories, while being overly crude and perverted and lacking any ounce of creativity and just so goddamn ugly I’m surprised my eyeballs haven’t withered up already. Not like due to lack of skill, its not like he can’t draw, but I’m pretty sure this is intentionally designed and drawn in a way to cause me maximal harm. I am saving you all so much trouble by not sharing more of this manga, but in case you want something that will casually be in a nightmare of yours two weeks from now, here is just a cute little treat.

This all pisses me off so much not just cause I like the genre, but since this is a relatively rare genre, when something like this comes out, it just pushes back the chance for a good one to come out in the same magazine! I just… hate this manga so much… I think this is the most angry I’ve been reading for this project by a long shot…

If you are morbidly curious to see some more (not fully NSFW but questionable and I would avoid it in a workspace personally) content from this manga, well, don't say I didn't warn you...




God I want to vomit…

Returning Series:

Kamo’s Negi:

Solid chapter, the baseball club is being used as a swindling operation by instituting behavioral fines, but got there was this multi-page monologue that just kept going on and on!

Zashisu:

Great chapter that is mostly a recap honestly, though it is a recap in a much more gruesome way!

This face sums up my experience:

Can We Live Together?:

Short commentary by me today, because we went from the best girl to an idol… she is alright, but probably tied for my least favorite character ngl. The chapter was fine and I’m sure our MC will protect her, but it feels more… juvenile? than the last story. Also I’ve never been able to get into media about idols, aside from Perfect Blue and Oshi no Ko, which each have very good premises surrounding their idol content.

Wear the Sky:

Get more time with this crazy new girl, and its enjoyable to watch her paint because she is very äø€ē”Ÿę‡øå‘½ about it!


Living in the Karakida Bookstore

Great admissions from Tsugumi about her personality and some silent reflections from Ichika about her love for her senpai!


Also, SHOCKING NEWS

Shrink:

Are we… Actually getting a nuanced take on drugs in Japan?

Holy shit I think we are!

Shrink, I’m proud of you! Good job!

And what a great note to end on, much better than how the read-through started!

Stay tuned in this feed for a new manga that I bet you haven’t heard of (that will have an anime in the next year or so!) and in the Harta thread for Harta 76 (finally!)

Also yeah any good genderswap/bodyswap manga recommendations are always appreciated! Hopefully something that redeems the genre from the monstrosity I read today…

6 Likes

oof the art in that first one, but the rest of the post pulled it up. Loved this:

4 Likes

I mentioned it in my rundown of current Harta series already, but J⇔M on Harta Alternative is surprisingly fun! A hitman and an elementary school girl body swap. Thankfully, considering that premise, there’s no gender or romantic comedy so it’s not really like Ranma 1/2 at all… but the focus instead on the swapped roles is fun - the girl’s smart and jaded and turns out to be a natural at feigning hard-boiled patter, while the hitman is a bit of a dork who never got a proper education and now has to keep up with homework, all while jobs keep coming in…

On Harta Alternative the first and most recent chapters are always freely available, which maybe makes it a bit awkward to catch up with since the intervening chapters aren’t readable at any given time…
The first and most recent are probably enough to try it out and start keeping up with a series though? Followed by then I guess filling in the gap with tankos when they come out if desired at that point.

3 Likes

ć™ć‚ć£ć·ā‡”ć™ć‚ć£ć·. Girl meets girl. Girl bumps into girl, and they accidentally kiss (as one does), discovering in the process that this causes them to swap bodies. It’s a Kirara manga, so that might give you an idea as to the general feel of the series. Only got four volumes, unfortunately.

4 Likes

Thanks for the recommendations! I’ll take a look at them!!

1 Like

I’m curious about Inside Mari, which I believe is from the Flowers of Evil mangka, so you know it’s going to break your brain.

Otherwise there’s at least one manga I have on my TBR which is something about a couple who are constantly swapping gender and are having a pretty good time with it. Might be one of my lewd ones idk

2 Likes

Fun fact! Inside Mari was pulled from sale by the censorship board here in Australia over concerns that it might be classified as child pornography. I haven’t been able to find out what the final ruling was, but as it still remains unavailable from Kinokuniya, either they decided to ban it, or Kinokuniya just decided not to skirt that line.

(I do know that volumes 1, 2 and 9 of the No Game No Life light novel series were banned.)

2 Likes

I’ve read Inside Mari (and its spiritual sequel, Okaeri Alice), and it was really interesting, but I feel like it didn’t stick the landing, at least according to my tastes! But I think even if you don’t like his works, Oshimi-sensei at the very least does not create anything bland!

Oh wow I had no idea! Yikes! I don’t remember it like that but it was almost a decade ago that I read it. Is Australia unusually censorship-happy?

No, usually books don’t need to be submitted for classification, but a ā€œwon’t somebody think of the children!ā€ type from South Australia (i.e. a completely different state from where Kinokuniya is located) made a formal complaint to the Australian Classification Board.

Was this Craig Kelly or Katter or something? I remember that brief broo hah hah

Nah, Connie Bonaros. Same sort of ilk, though.

Monthly action ceasing publication :frowning:

3 Likes