鋼の錬金術師 Volume 3

Volume 3 Discussion Thread

鋼の錬金術師 Offshoot Home Thread

Vocabulary Lists

Reading Schedule

Week Start Date Pages No. of Pages Chapter
Week 1 October 26 7–50 43 pages 第 9 話
Week 2 November 02 51–86 35 pages 第 10 話
Week 3 November 09 87–128 41 pages 第 11 話
Week 4 November 16 129–172 43 pages 第 12 話
Week 5 November 23 173–185 12 pages 外伝 + おまけ

Discussion Rules

  • If you have any questions, don’t hesitate to ask.
  • Please mention the chapter and page number.
  • Please use spoiler tags for major events.
  • If you read ahead, please hold questions until during or after the appropriate week.

Chapter 9

Start Date: October 26

Participation

Mark your participation status by voting in this poll. (You can change your answer later if you’d like.)

  • I’m reading along.
  • I have finished this part.
  • I will catch up later.
0 voters

OH! NO!!

The young women in this manga have a severe case of sameface.

How many young women have there been so far?

The orphan in the first chapter, the one soldier with Mustang and now the mechanic. I think the mum looked pretty similar too although I don’t remember precisely.

p37

Can somebody explicit the user of 兼ねて here? I know that it often means that something is hard/impossible, but it doesn’t make sense here. So is it about doing two things at once? As in testing both their new armors at once?

Why more face, when one face do trick?

(Lust from the last chapter)

… It means “for quite a while”.

wat

Sometimes what looks like conjugated form can turn into a new vocabulary.

It’s also a grammar point.

Right but that’s the “doing concurrently” meaning I was taking about, no? But what is done concurrently here?

I’m talking about the bunpro item, the jpdb one says what @Belthazar was taking about.

Oh actually 兼ねて is in jmdict too, I missed it because 予て came first and I rejected it based on the kanji form.

Just simply both “testing out the new armor” and “doing training sparring”. It’s the verb ()ねる.

stem- ()ねる won’t have a particle. Goo JE separates both cleanly.

かねて thing in the front or something is a different vocabulary, like かねてより、

Ok I think I got it, I think I just need to take this use of 兼ねて as a special case distinct from the other uses of 兼ねる. Technically I suppose that there’s always a similar underlying idea but it seems a bit too abstract to be useful for me.

ch9

Good stuff:

  • Armstrong. Fucking MVP.

Meh stuff:

  • blablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablablabla

Your mum died and you messed up with alchemy, we got it, now quit yapping and move the bloody story forward. We’re at volume 3 and I feel like it’s still the intro somehow.

I guess this time we heard about Chekhov’s disappeared dad though.

Did you want backstory or not? :stuck_out_tongue:

In all seriousness, though, FMA is a single story arc that lasts for twenty-seven volumes. You can’t expect that anything’s gonna be resolved by the third.

Yeah I’m starting to think that it’s a bit too slow-paced for me, although I guess part of the issue is that it’s also a challenging read for me so I progress slowly. If I was reading this in a language I’m more fluent in I could just power through the volumes and the pacing wouldn’t be as much of an issue I think.

The payoff is worth it, though. And you’ll be pretty fluent by the end. :slightly_smiling_face:

Ok. If Armstrong dies I’m out tho.

Yeah, I agree this chapter was spinning the wheels a bit story-wise, but I found this week a bit easier to read, so was able to go through it fairly quickly. I think the manga is still in the “introducing new characters” phase. No doubt we will see these characters again and I can see how it was important to spend a little time with them.

I’m still enjoying it and I think the quality of the art is pretty good.