香君 上 西から来た少女 Advanced Book Club

I do have a question. Did you read the character list and if so was it useful so far?

4 Likes

No, I did not read the character list up until now (I am near the end of week 2 now). Firstly because I did not want to spoil myself, and secondly because I figured I might not remember the names anyway :sweat_smile:

Some spoiler-free details about how many characters appear etc

Right from the start, the reader gets pretty much flooded with various characters and their names, as I think is kinda typical for the author. I had a bit of a hard time with them, struggling my way through the first week, and then I slowly started to form a mental picture of the main characters. During week 2, this picture got much clearer, and for now I feel ok with most of the characters that appeared so far. Maybe later on I need to have a look at the character list or write my own list though…

8 Likes

We start reading today! I’ve posted the week one discussion thread:

5 Likes

Week 2 thread is now up:

2 Likes

I’ve posted the week three thread a touch early, because I’m going to be busy most of tomorrow:

4 Likes

Week 4 starts today: we cover chapters 2.2 and 2.3.

2 Likes

The week 5 thread is up; this week we read chapters 2.3, 2.4, and 2.5. At 45 pages this is the longest week in the schedule.

5 Likes

The books currently have a 30% coinback campaign on Bookwalker, if anyone is interested in buying future volumes*.

*affiliate link

4 Likes

Week six is up, where we will read another three chapters (but not quite finish this volume yet):

3 Likes

I’ve put the week seven thread up a little early as I will be busy tomorrow morning. This is the week when (if you’re reading the four volume edition) we finish the last part of book one and start on book two.

1 Like

I was looking at the schedule and wondering why next week said 30 pages when in my copy it looked like 3.7 alone was 31 pages. Turns out the two book ebook (kindle) is missing the TOC entry for 3.8! Hopefully the break is still there and it’s just missing from the TOC.

4 Likes

If you want the last phrase in 3.7, it’s 私は決して、あなたに強いはしないわ. Hopefully it’s just the TOC being wrong, though.

4 Likes

And the week eight thread is now up:

1 Like

Should we start discussing the schedule for the next book?

2 Likes

Should we use the same pace? And have another 12 weeks to finish the story.

1 Like

I’d like to follow the same pace at least. I don’t know how long the rest is, so would it be 12 weeks?

1 Like

The other question is whether people want a short break before starting book 3, or just to roll straight into it.

3 Likes

I’m not even done with book 2, so I’ve become resigned to the fact that I’ll never catch up anyway and will leave the choice to you :hot_face:

4 Likes

Natively says the books are 256/224/256/240 pages, so there’s only 16 pages different – I haven’t looked at chapter lengths, but it will probably come out to 12 or 13 weeks for books three and four.

4 Likes

Week nine is up:

Here are some polls to gauge interest in an informal followon club to read volumes three and four:

  • I would like to read along with a group for volumes three and four
  • I plan to finish the book but will do it at my own pace
  • I’m going to stop at the end of book two
0 voters
  • I’d like to go straight from book two into book three
  • I’d prefer a short two week break before we start book three
0 voters

Feel free to comment if the above doesn’t quite express your preferences.

3 Likes