Week 3: 十角館の殺人

Join the Murder Mystery Series Meta Book Club here!

十角館の殺人 Home Thread

Week 3

Start Date: May 23
Previous Part: Week 2
Next Part: Week 4

Reading:

Week Start Date Chapter Page Count
Week 3 May 23 Chapter 2 ~52

Discussion Rules

  • Please use spoiler tags for major events in the current chapter(s) and any content in future chapters.
  • When asking for help, please mention the chapter and page number. Also mention what version of the book you are reading.
  • Don’t be afraid of asking questions, even if they seem embarrassing at first. All of us are here to learn.
  • To you lurkers out there: Join the conversation, it’s fun! :durtle:

Participants

Mark your participation status by voting in this poll.
(Please feel free to update your status whenever you like!)

  • I’m reading along
  • I have finished this part
  • I’m still reading the book but I haven’t reached this part yet
  • I am no longer reading the book
0 voters

This week felt a little easier to me than the other ones. I think it’s mainly an effect of there being more dialog. It was mainly people talking and making plans.

Thoughts

I was pretty surprised that they all thought wapros were something pretty rare. The book came out in 1987. I’ve thought wapros would have been pretty common by then. That just shows you how much the world has changed in that relative short time frame on one hand. On the other hand most things are still the same, and we can easily read a book from that time period without it feeling too dated. Close to 40 years, man.

I quite like our protagonists on the mainland so far. They all have their own quirks, and I think they are a more harmonious bunch compared to our group on the island.
What shocked me was the backstory of 千織. I feel like they more or less brushed it off. If something like that would happen to me, I would be devastated much harder. Sure 江南 is feeling some regret, but honestly he is probably one that isn’t mainly at fault.

I’m not sure if it is helpful that the book is split into island and mainland storylines. I feel like when we go back to the island in next week’s reading I will have already forgotten pretty much everything about the story that is going on over there. But it’s probably necessary for the book to work, so I leave my judgment for after when we finish the book.

EDIT: was also happy to see がてら used in this weeks reading. Since I started learning N1 grammar I appreciate it actually being used somewhere.

After much reflection, I think I’m reading too many books at the moment, so I will likely be reading on ahead of this one to finish up early. I’m just re-reading for fun anyway; if the club votes to continue reading this series, I’ll definitely be joining you guys for initial reads. :flexed_biceps:

Already, I’ll post my thoughts here for this week once I finish.

Definitely a long week; not too bad since I’ve had more free time than usual to read, but it might be a tough sell on a usually-busy week. Anyhow, we jump to what I remember as the mainlanders having the time, energy, and interest in deep-diving on the mysteries at large, sometimes tediously. :sweat_smile: Anyway, we’ve got 島田、河南、and 守須. So if I’m understanding the timeline here correctly, 中村青司 and his household died before 千織, right? She died a few months after them?

Hu, I thought it’s the exact other way around. She died at the new years party a year ago. The fire was roughly six months ago.

Current month: march
Island incident: august-september
Chiori: new years party before

But maybe I misunderstood and chiori is only 2 months and a bit ago. That would be even more shocking to me since they are all instantly fine again.

Don’t have time currently to look it up in the book so someone else confirming or denying would be helpful.

Ah, I think you’re probably right. :person_facepalming: I keep flipping the order of events around in my head for some reason.

Everybody probably knows this by now, but just to put it down here as well, at the start of chapter 3 (i.e. next week) we get the confirmation that @downtimes is right regarding the timeline of events. :+1:

I’m also not convinced by the dual storyline idea, especially since the island has so many characters to keep track of. Maybe it would be more manageable if I were a native speaker who could finish a chapter a day.

So far I like the book fairly well anyway.