Using が with ある

I was watching Misa’s video on ある & いる + particles and she says when using ある it’s usually paired with the particle が. Hence the structure: object がある. Why is this so? From my limited knowledge, the only usage of the が particle I know is to put emphasis on a subject or identify something.

(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1e4jyTdR8ig)

が is the default subject marker. It is not only for emphasis or introducing new information.

3 Likes

Right I see. Thanks Leebo! You’ve been really helpful.

2 Likes

Highly recommending Tae Kim’s writing on this here and here!

1 Like

Cure Dolly also made a good video on Japanese sentence structure and が

If you don’t like her voice just mute it, use subtitles and probably increase the speed.

3 Likes

You know how it would be weird to say “I’m going to the party” if the person you’re talking to doesn’t know about the party? That’s because using “the” implies that the speaker expects the listener to already know about what follows it (which is the “party,” in this example).

The は particle in Japanese is similar to English’s “the” in this sense: because は is used to provide context and redirect the conversation to a new topic, it is weird to shift the topic into something that your listener doesn’t know anything about.

So, to use は properly, we should be using it only on things that our listener is familiar with.

 

Therefore, if we want to introduce something new to the listener, for example… what even exists… we use が instead. Once something has been introduced to the listener with が, it can be correctly referenced later with は.

(Also, I suspect that this is why it’s said that が can be used to emphasize what comes before it; if our listener is already familiar with something, meaning we can safely use は on it, yet we still choose to use in spite of that, it shifts some extra attention onto whatever this particle is marking.)


Reference: https://8020japanese.com/wa-vs-ga/
(Scroll down to “The true purpose of ‘wa’”)

7 Likes

This topic was automatically closed 365 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.