Has to be rare for learners to get as good at remembering the reading for 煙管 as us, haha. I don’t think I had even seen it before this VN.
The Definition of a Witch
I feel like I don’t have too much to add in insight, but I’m enjoying where this chapter goes. It’s a big swing that the overall story has taken from the initial setup of the murders, into making the meta layer game more important, to now working off Beatrice’s character in this way where the game is secondary to her and Battler’s relationship.
The George stuff, besides showing a way someone becomes like Kinzo, feels like it mostly reaffirms what we’ve been talking about with magic and belief previously. The little bob their sprites do to indicate flight is cute, haha.
Ultimately if I was following the point of the earlier discussions correctly the lives are like the broken pot, right? Even if Shannon is coming back it won’t be for long before she… breaks again . In my previous read of half of this in English years ago I went to a little ways into episode 5 but I genuinely don’t recall where Ch 3 is going anymore at this point, most of my clear memories of it were the earlier events surrounding finding the gold and Eva Beatrice, so I’m genuinely not sure! Well I remember one more thing late in the episode but it’s more on the meta layer.
Ok I once again piled a bunch of reading together in the readathon, did 61k characters to finish the chapter and the first tea party.
Chapter 3 ending
Well, that event at the end really dominates how I can talk about anything that happened previously. I will say the VN was pretty touching at times, like the description of Shannon returning from the land of the dead – it’s like what I was saying before, ryukishi is willing to go FAR into cheese and I think doing that he hits on some really poignant moments.
I am at a loss for how to explain the red truths that Beatrice has to take the nuclear option to. The thing about Kyrie having another motive was SUPER obvious because I was thinking the food thing was way too suspicious even before getting to them bringing it up, but that final assault seems pretty airtight. I’m missing where the trick is.
But anyway, the big thing is that Beatrice’s whole turn around to becoming a true witch who understands the value of 有限, of life itself, and nicely grants people’s desires is fake…maybe? I’m leaning towards there being more truth to all that than she lets on and the game ulterior motive being a sort of kayfabe to keep the game with Battler going as is. Her and Virgilia do drop the act and make the trick obvious BEFORE the new character appears (is it obvious who it is? I can’t un-know now so I wonder). I definitely think the stuff about Beatrice wanting Battler to find the real truth on his own is legitimately real, if nothing else. Like her game is probably more about that than anything else?
So… Eva did it, I guess. This time only? It’s weird how obvious she is as the culprit, though we still don’t know how she could have done, if nothing else, the Nanjo murder. It also really makes me wonder why Hideyoshi actually died if he truly was being an accomplice in some way. Perhaps he knew he was an accomplice to her sneaking out for SOMETHING (gold-related?) but then discovered she was the murderer? I’m so sold on their relationship it’s hard for me to think of her actually killing him honestly. To say nothing of George being killed, too… 全然駄目だぜ。
I went past the numbers a bit quickly because I was doing the readathon as fast as possible, but I have no idea as of now. I’ll have to look back and think about them a bit more. Got a screenshot to reference:
Most of this is the witches teasing each other over the identity of the girl, and we get the psychotic yuri vibes here out of Lambda, haha.
The stuff about her allowing Beatrice to be a witch and being the real force behind this game is quite interesting, though I’m not sure I have much more to say other than “wow that sure sounds important!” The reality of Beatrice’s existence and role has become perhaps the slipperiest part of this whole story.
Oh and I was so happy they brought up the えば thing like in 死んじゃえば, I had thought to myself she says her name all the time but I thought that was a really dumb joke. Funny to see it called out.
Right, I should share my (spoiler) impressions of this chapter too
I remember liking 3 in the past, and I quite enjoyed it again this time. It feels like the chapter is doing a lot to help us understand how the VN’s world operates: here’s how you should think about magic, here’s how you need to skeptical of events as presented, here are hints to the riddle, etc. All the same, I come out of it feeling like despite all I learned and got better equipped to tackle this, I’m more confused than ever. Which I think is good, especially for the stage we’re at. The final murder is pretty baffling, and we’re so in the dark about what’s real and what isn’t about Beatrice.
I like basically all the character additions. Eva-Beatrice is fun to watch as someone totally drunk on magic power, and having a person actually solve the riddle so early is a big shock. Ronove’s personality is great and he feels like core cast already, though it is hard to know how much “real” Ronove we see and how much is all part of a grand play. That goes doubly for Virgilia, maybe the most confusing character we have. She’s decent but I have no idea what to think about who she really is and what’s true or not about her. I even like the two rabbit sisters – they’re pushing it on this game’s ridiculousness but I dunno, something about them amuses me. Their blocks of kanji were annoying stumbling points when I tried to read as quickly as possible through the readathon, but I forgive them, haha.
Perhaps some of the action stuff goes a little long for me, but I am used to ryukishi indulging himself in those scenes. He’s worse about it in Higurashi, which I still love dearly, haha.
Of course this also sets up a very strong hook for the next episode, which is our final question arc! Exciting.
And, finally, I will be waiting for you to catch up (I need to read the ??? epilogue anyway still), but I went ahead and made the episode 4 thread while it’s on my mind
oh man, we’re at the end of EP3? I had a super-convoluted system set up, like, a decade ago to play original PC graphics with voice acting, gonna have to see if I can get that back up despite being on a different computer and OS…
EP3
The Sun and the North Wind, amirite? As I said in an earlier post, I still have no idea if everything with Beato (and her beef with Evatrice) was real, or if even that was nothing more than a ploy to get Battler to acknowledge her as a witch (as he almost did).
Alright, I took very, very good notes on all 3 EPs so far. (I did it in Excel, so I easily see that have 500+ individuals notes per EP lol.) I also went very deep into theorycrafting for the first 2 EPs. I never got around to it for EP3 cuz there was a fair amount where there just didn’t seem to be much wiggle room…
I did remember that the “web of reds” at the end had a trivial loophole. Specifically, the culprit just had to commit suicide after killing Nanjo. Then you can give the “These 15 are dead” and “Jessica, Battler, and Eva are inno” reds no problem.
The way I would like the story to be crafted would be for the fantasy to cover the truth of reality. We know (as much as we can know anything in this game) that there was a real Beatrice in a second hidden mansion who died. Kumasawa turns into Virgilia, who is Beatrice’s teacher. So I think that Kumasawa was also the real Beatrice’s mentor (possibly mother?). Dunno how that fits into the motives and background and whatnot but just a thought that I had.
Also, looking back at my notes, my most-hated scene (from a trying-to-solve-the-mystery perspective) was actually in EP2. (It’s the scene where “Kanon”(?) shows up at the servant’s room and kills everyone.)
I had kind of an interesting experience playing this where I happened to stop playing right after George and Beato revived Shannon, and then I came back a day later to continue it, and literally like the very next line, George and Shannon both died, lol. So I spent a whole day wondering about how that revival was going to change things only for them to immediately die in the story.
Kinda funny how time works.
This was an interesting chapter because Beato seemed to genuinely have a revelation about the true nature of magic here and she seemed probably the most human we have ever seen her. I’m really looking forward to the mind palace version of Battler meeting her again now. For the first time, I was rooting for her to get away, haha. It was sweet of Virgilia to sacrifice herself for Beato, though I admit I don’t really understand how that was able to happen if Virgilia died already this chapter?? Oh well.
Krauss and Natsuhi got got, too. With only 4 people left, aren’t we already over the number of sacrifices required? Eva Beatrice certainly seems to love a good bloodbath, though, so maybe she’ll take out the rest just for the fun of it.
Also, Nanjo randomly seeming to catch on to Beato’s motivation surprised me a bit. As soon as Battler started talking about the windows, Nanjo seemed suspicious to me, to be honest… We technically saw onscreen how George left and how the others got murdered, so it feels strange to doubt that, but I dunno. In the spirit of the game and all…
Wow, long final chapter, haha. But I finished it! All that’s left now are the extras, which I’ll save for another time.
18:03 The Witch’s Courtroom
Ok, we have a number written on the door in the blood-like red paint: 07151129. Actually, reading a little more, it sounds like this one might be written in actual blood… Battler thinks it’s a date because his birthday just so happens to be July 15. Does that leave 1129 as the year?? I looked up the year on wikipedia just for fun, and nothing immediately leapt out at me… I suppose it could also be a time as well? Just as I was thinking that, Battler decided it’s another date: November 29.
Wait, hang on, Battler says: “……11月29日が、誰かの誕生日だったりとかするのか?うちの家族は違うぜ、親父も霧江さんも縁寿も違う。もちろん俺のお袋もだ.” Who is 縁寿??
I got so distracted by the number, I totally forgot they were there to find George’s body…
The characters list says: “In exchange for his soul, the witch granted an 8-digit number. 07151129. When spoken, a small Golden Land will be opened.”
???
I still haven’t given up entirely on my sweetfish mackerel theory, so I’m noting for the record that the mackerel came up again in this episode with Battler thinking back on yesterday’s lunch and saying that it would’ve been funny if Kumasawa had put grilled mackerel in the cookies she’d baked.
Alright, 縁寿 comes up again: she’s Rudolph and Kirie’s daughter. 6 years old, apparently. Am I crazy, or has this character’s existence never been mentioned before??
Also, it’s kind of strange to me that the guesthouse’s doors and windows can’t be locked from the outside. Isn’t that counterintuitive for a building? I suppose they are on a private island, so maybe they don’t care about being able to lock up when no one’s in there, but considering how paranoid the characters are about checking the locks in the main house, it seems strange that they’d willingly leave the guesthouse unlocked all the time.
It’s kind of ironic that Jessica is so convinced that Eva killed her parents, lol. Well I mean…
Also wow that gunshot startled me, hahaha. I also love the way that Eva Beatrice appeared very suddenly right after Nanjo opened the door. Those are fun things a VN can do that a regular novel (or manga, for that matter) can’t do.
That was a sweet gesture that Beato did for Jessica and Kanon, though I did kind of start getting bored of the heterosexual lovey-dovey stuff in the scene that followed lol.
Loved the scene with Beato enduring all the attacks. That was really moving. And then Battler uniting with her was super cool. It felt really satisfying.
Okay, I’m a bit confused here. Eva Beatrice said in red: “人間以外の生命は一切、このゲームに関係がない。” If they’re saying that no lifeforms other than humans have any connection to this game, then doesn’t that… exclude witches?? I guess they’re sometimes unclear with the language. Maybe it’s a distinction between 人間 and ニンゲン? Eva Beatrice said she wasn’t a ニンゲン, but I guess that doesn’t necessarily preclude her from being a 人間.
Cool moment of trust between Beato and Battler with Battler covering his ears so that he wouldn’t hear Beato deny her own existence in red.
In the so-called Golden Land, I did not like the part where Rudolph and Kirie implied that Rudolph would seduce any woman Battler brought home . Just a gross, unnecessary thing to say.
As soon as they brought out the contract, I started getting suspicious, and sure enough…
Cool dramatic moment where Virgilia’s eyes opened there at the very end for the first time (the art does such a good job of being very unsettling in this VN), and they are also blue! I’m probably fixating on totally useless information whenever I mention that, lol, but I’ve been waiting this whole VN to see her eyes, ever since noticing that Eva Beatrice’s are blue.
And we have a new character!
The random woman that showed up at the end has the same hair color as Battler and also blue eyes (like his), so I’m going to randomly guess that she’s his (twin?) sister or something? Maybe Kirie’s kid actually survived?
Wait, hang on, in the end credits, I saw a new name in there: Ushiromiya Ange. I’m guessing that’s the romanization for 縁寿? But wait, she’s supposed to be 6 years old, right? So that can’t be the woman who showed up unless there’s something weird going on here (which I will never rule out, lol). I suppose if a younger version of Eva can be another character in this, an older version of Ange could also be a character? Sure, why not.
I also laughed at “All the goats” in the credits. Just an extremely funny way to phrase that. Shout out to all the goats!
Yeah, I also struggled… I paused for a bit to try to think about it and look for any holes in the wording. My best idea was that one of the dead people was actually not dead yet at the time of killing Nanjo, but was dead before Nanjo was dead. But I dunno. I gave up on trying to figure that one out for now.
Yeah, I also think there’s more truth to all of that than she lets on because if magic works based on belief, then Beato herself has to on some level believe in the power of love and all of that mushy stuff in order to pull off the things that she did. I think genuinely her main motivation above all else is the game with Battler, and wanting to get a fully satisfying win out of it, and I think in order to do that, she’s willing to do just about anything, including change her own nature if that’s what it takes.
Actually, if there’s a reason to doubt the whole thing being a trick that Beato pulled, it’s that I don’t think she’d want to have Battler acknowledge her as a witch by tricking him into signing a piece of paper. That voids the whole chess game, does it not? Why go through all the trouble of risking her own existence like that in order to prevent him from acknowledging magic against Eva Beatrice only to pull a super cheap trick of her own that would also unceremoniously end the game? I think she did what she felt she had to do to keep the game going.
To use a wrestling analogy, she made herself the heel so that Battler would continue to fight her as an opponent.
Yeah, it was so obvious that she did it, it makes me inclined to suspect that it wasn’t all her somehow… Maybe not the first set of murders, at least? Since she hadn’t solved the epitaph at the time. Not sure about Nanjo, either. The logic seems to pretty much totally rule her out as a possibility for that one. And we didn’t technically see the Hideyoshi murder onscreen, if I recall correctly, which makes me suspicious of that, too. He’s so suspicious this whole episode…
Though honestly, my first thought with the cigarettes is that that would be a profoundly easy object for Eva Beatrice to plant in order to coax several people to leave the guesthouse, therefore setting up the opportunity for the next sacrifices. So maybe it wasn’t even his cigarette butt in the first place.
I’ll type up another post after I’ve finished all the extras with my full thoughts on the “whodunit” aspect of this episode.
Oh I didn’t catch that! Thanks. That door was where George and Shannon were right? I guess their meeting “place” was a Golden Land? Feels like there’s a clue there.
The first time I read this I had the same exact reaction! Thought she came out of nowhere. This time through, because it would catch my eye more, I can say there IS a reference or two to her. I can’t say for sure if it was all the way back in episode 1 or what but there is a brief mention or two to Battler having a sister and her not coming here. It’s quick and not much attention is drawn to it.
I’m pretty sure Ange is referenced (maybe not by name?) at the beginning of EP1. Very “blink and you’ll miss it”. But yeah, surprise imouto to save the day!
Also (if it wasn’t already cleared up), the final scene with Ange takes place 10 (iirc) years later, which is why she’s a teen and not a 6 year old.
Had a really busy week and couldn’t get around to this as fast as I would’ve liked, but I finally finished the rest of the episode 3 material!
It was 3,570 characters for the Tea Party, and then 8,265 for the other extra. Here are some thoughts:
Tea Party
My friend had hinted that there was something between Bernkastel and Lambdadelta, so I was paying a little more attention to them because of that, and that seems to have fully become canon text in this scene haha.
Interesting how Lambda sort of hides her true self in front of Bern and acts ditzier than she is.
Also really interesting finding out that Lambda is apparently the one pulling the strings for Beatrice?? I didn’t expect that at all. That actually painted Beatrice’s actions in this episode in a different light for me. It makes me a lot more inclined to believe she was more genuine than she let on, but she had to do what she did to Battler in the end because she had to serve Lambda’s wishes.
Also, the pumpkin on Lambda’s dress… Now I wonder if some of the pumpkin stuff Beato did wasn’t so much for Maria’s benefit as it was for Lambda’s?
HAHA same! I thought I was just noticing because I was a language learner haha. I was assuming that it was a case of a natural Japanese phrase standing out to me in a way that it wouldn’t with a native speaker lol.
The other extra
12 YEARS LATER??
OK, we’re in a hospital room that is apparently Eva’s, and she has aged unnaturally early and seems to be dying. Ange is visiting. Is Eva going to use magic to send Ange back in time to stop Beatrice or something?
Also, yeah, just as I was thinking that Eva’s condition reminded me a lot of Kinzo, the VN directly compared them, saying that her remaining lifespan had become exactly the same as Kinzo’s from back then.
It’s really sad that Eva thinks of Ange as having stolen away the future she built for George… Ange was just a child and had no agency in that entire situation.
Honestly can’t really fault Eva’s plan of cursing Ange by simply giving her all of the money and the Beatrice title… Genuinely none of that seems to have brought anyone any good.
Uh oh lol Eva having her own version of a Kinzo phase by inviting in a bunch of random religious leaders. Is this how she’s going to send Ange back in time?
Hahaha I had never encountered the word 魔法瓶 before! What a way to say thermos…
Judging by her speech patterns, Eva seems to have fully merged with Eva Beatrice. She also says she passed down the name of the Golden Witch Beatrice to Ange? Hmm… Maybe Ange took herself back in time to find out the truth, then?
Well, I was wrong about Eva being the one to send her back; looks like Bern just interfered directly, lol.
Ange as the final Beatrice…
One thing I found kind of interesting is that my initial assumption was that Eva and Eva Beatrice had basically melded, but the implication from the narrative seems to be that Eva just developed into this version of herself over time due to her environment and circumstances moulding her into it. Kind of an example of it not actually being magic, but just the power of belief (other people’s belief in the witch being real) shaping Eva into the being they thought of her as.
I also thought back to Maria from the end of episode 1 and her trying to solve the mystery. Reminded me a lot of Ange. Now I wonder if that was Bern’s doing, too?
Also, since Bern is so partial to people who are trapped like she was, I wonder if she’ll start to sympathize with Beato’s situation, too…
I feel like this whole VN has been figuring out there is a villain behind the villain, haha.
Alright, this is all I have time for right now. But when I get the time, I am going to make another post with my theories/impressions on the episode, and will finally read and respond to everyone else’s!
Eva’s voice actor is doing some good work here. So yeah, the money really ruined everyone’s lives. Honestly reminds me – I only really know about one of my grandmothers through what my mother told me about her, so there’s probably some distortion… but it is also true I didn’t know her because she didn’t want to bother seeing me, heh. But basically she had, not even a lot of money? Like slightly above average it seems like, and the impression I got is she just kind of sat around hoarding as much as she could and increasingly spent the later part of her life re-configuring who would get how much, or at least threatening to, based on which of her kids she was most pleased or angry with that day. Really can take over your life.
This is a nice hook to show us how next episode will be different, and I really like the quick image of Angie in front of the moon.
Being a witch, like you said ties into public opinion here, and also seems to just automatically come with any woman who is in control of the Ushiromiya fortune. Kinzo himself was known for his magic stuff but it feels like there’s some relevance to the gender things going on that as a man he was an eccentric guy who dabbled in magic while any time the fortune is mentioned with a woman she is immediately a witch, as like her core identity. Was original Beatrice literally just a rich lady? lol
(This part isn’t spoilers, so I can talk about it out here, haha.)
I actually got my parents interested in playing this VN by describing some of the family stuff, which they found really relatable considering my dad’s current experience with his siblings… Though I didn’t end up helping them install it because I feel like if they do play it and like it, they’ll probably get ahead of me pretty quickly and might accidentally spoil me… . Maybe when I’m further along I’ll see if they’re still interested, haha. They both like mysteries but are neutral on anime and haven’t really experienced a VN before, so it’s hard to say if they’d like it or not.
Now, here are my thoughts on episode 3 and my theories for WHO DID IT
First of all, I really liked this episode overall! It’s definitely my favorite one so far. Really great stuff with Beatrice specifically. I think out of all of the episodes so far, this was the most emotionally moving one for me. The twist at the end is very cruel in that regard, but I feel like what was presented wasn’t the full story, so I’m still willing to give Beato the benefit of the doubt haha.
Regarding my suspects, I guess I’ll say that right off the bat, I do think that Eva/Eva Beatrice (does a distinction here matter?) did most of the murders in this episode, but I don’t think she did the very first set.
So, with that out of the way, here are my guesses for the primary puller of the strings…
My suspects based on wordplay epitaph trickery:
Kumasawa
As I mentioned before, I suspect her because of her mackerel in desserts joke. “Sweetfish”. I went down a brief rabbit hole initially with this theory because I wondered if “sweet + fish” was also an inherent association in the original Japanese, and then that was answered definitively in this episode because they mentioned the fish having a sweet smell. It’s also sometimes written 香魚. So the mackerel sweetfish theory lives!
Another point of suspicion for me is the fact that we never actually saw her die this time, since she was Virgilia in disguise the final time we saw her.
Gohda
As I mentioned earlier, I suspected Gohda because his name has a 郷 in it: 郷田俊郎. At first I kind of dismissed this, because it didn’t seem like it would translate very well, but then I realized that in English, if we’re calling it the “Golden Land” and such, “Go” is the first sound in “Gold”, so you can make it work in English as well!
Still a pretty flimsy reason, but to be honest, he’s been high on my list of suspects this whole time lol.
The “sweetfish” mackerel thing also sort of connects back to Gohda as well, since he’s the one making the desserts. Maybe the initial clues are pointing toward the kitchen specifically? I dunno.
My suspects based on other factors:
Hideyoshi
I’m back to suspecting him. The cigarette thing with Kirie seems to suggest that at the very least, he covered for Eva (unless the cigarette was planted, which I’m still suspicious of as a possibility), and of course I still harbor suspicions from episode 1, lol.
Nanjo
Nanjo has always been kind of quietly suspicious to me, to be honest. There’s the chess game with Kinzo, and the fact that he’s in a good position to give the others bad information (though Beato’s addition of speaking in red sort of negates anyone’s ability to fake deaths). In this episode, he was kind of hovering around in the background in a convenient position where no one else was really with him or watching him.
All in all, I think my prime suspect this time around is…
GOHDA.
Since this is the epitaph wordplay episode, I will go with the strongest epitaph wordplay suspect!
Though I don’t really have any suspect I can accuse with confidence…
I heard that there’s one singular culprit behind all the murders in all the EPs, so that’s how I’ve done my theorizing. But this one was so long ago and the stupid stuff about the cigarette make it hard to not doubt Eva/Hideyoshi in some capacity, even though I didn’t think they did it in the previous EPs.
Anyway, despite the amount of time that’s passed, one line that still sticks out to me is Battler’s suggestion of alternate personalities, which was made in a really awkward spot where it didn’t make much sense, and which was denied without reds. I really really really don’t want to think about it because it was suggested in a place where it doesn’t make much sense, and I think it’s an extremely stupid way of sidestepping an “X is dead” red, but if that is the solution I could totally see that line as a clunky way to introduce the concept to be “fair.”
I believe that the first set is done by the same person in all the episodes, or at least the same person sends the first letter/kicks off the murders, but additional people can die after that who are killed by someone else.
As for your other theory, I talked about that a lot in the thread for the previous episode. That’s something that has been on my mind, too. I agree with not wanting it to be the case…
I guess we’ll find out for ourselves. That opens up the solution space by a ton, which I think would make it a lot harder. If that is the case tho, I will say it’s very nice of the copycats to always continue to follow the epitaph xP