Regardingト as a radical

a minor gripe about this radical specifically. came up in review and i failed it by typing “to”. in my mind, I am thinking the sound “toe” and conjuring the concept of a toe, but while I’m studying Japanese everything naturally tends towards Japanese pronunciation. essentially I answered the radical in romanji.

part of me is just annoyed i got it wrong when actively thinking the right thing, but another part of me is annoyed that I feel like i’m being forced to shift back over to english to answer a question for my japanese study.

would it be too disruptive to accept romanji answers in corner cases like this? to be clear i am specifically talking about radicals and not Kanji, so it’s not like i’m asking for it to accept an answers that would be wrong to Japanese people

1 Like

But what is the romaji answer for radical like 工 : construction ?
Do you really want to type konnsutorakushonn ?

If yes, I think you can add a synonym:

One option is to add a user synonym in cases like these. Might be a bit of a bother having to do it frequently, but it only takes a few seconds to do.

1 Like

I understand what you want to say. ト is a radical with meaning “toe” but it is a katakana also and the reading is “to”. That is the reason to the confusion right?

To be fair, it’s never an issue for construction. I think as Joagedelhajp correctly points out the issue is specifically that the name they chose for the radical is also the sound it makes as itself as a katakana character. there is this reinforcement built up in my mind already that “ト” is “to” (read as “toe”), and it’s so close to the radical that trying to remember to put the e on the end feels counter-intuitive.

4 Likes

@TofuguJenny See here please because it is an important issue about the ト radical.

How do y’all live without undo scripts, I’ll never understand. Life is too short to review the “toe” radical twenty times for no reason.

4 Likes

I could go by T.O., as there is a company by that name here. (And there is also TO books.)

It’s Roma (), rather than Roman. Ancient Rome, I think.

Thank you for pointing this out. I’ve added “to” as an “allowed” answer, which means it isn’t publicly visible, but it will now be accepted during lessons and reviews. :slight_smile:

4 Likes