Reading Vol. 9・ふらいんぐうぃっち・Flying Witch (Beginner Book Club) 🧹

I haven’t started vol 8 yet :sweat_smile: But I’m planning to soon. I think a little break between vol 8 and 9 would be nice. But I also can’t guarantee that I’ll be able to catch all the way up in that time, or that I’ll be able to be that participatory after I do catch up, so I feel bad making everyone else wait if they’d rather keep going. I’m basically going to be dying under a pile of work until the end of February (at least), so… :stuck_out_tongue:

3 Likes

w00t, finally started volume 8 today…

why wait a few years? :face_with_raised_eyebrow:

4 Likes

Okay, it looks like a short break at least is definitely in order :slightly_smiling_face: let’s aim for 2nd January, and no pressure on anybody who isn’t able to catch up in that time anyway. We’ll have to wait until the summer for volume 10, I imagine.

6 Likes

Are we still looking to start January 2nd, or do we need to check in again on who’s ready?

Do you plan to handle the thread, @Radish8, or would you like me to? I do other book club posts the same day of the week, so it’s no burden on me for one more.

2 Likes

If you think it would be a good idea!

  • I can start on the 2nd
  • I can’t start now, but waiting till February would let me join in
  • I will be behind either way!

0 voters

I’ll get the thread ready to deploy either way. If you’re happy to do the weekly posts I’d be very grateful. It feels more appropriate given that I’m not reading along :slightly_smiling_face:

@Nenad @NicoleRauch @Kappa420 @denzo @Kumirei @2OC3aOdKgwSGlxfz @windupbird

5 Likes

Alright, I reckon we should just go for it as planned.

All yours, @ChristopherFritz!

(If you could add the onwards link to the volume 8 OP as well that would be fab.)

3 Likes

since I couldn’t find your level 60 thread.
pardon me but I have to spam the thread to congrat you on your level 60, @Radish8 !
You made it.
I still vividly remember when you were just beginning your wk journey~~.
Congratulations :partying_face:

3 Likes

Aaah, thank you! :purple_heart: :blush: It’s funny to think back on then vs now. Looks like you’re nearly there too!

2 Likes

Out of curiosity, when did you start?

Around December 2017, I think - I got to level 40 in 2018, had an… unexpectedly long break in 2019 (only about three months where I stopped reviews as well as lessons though) and then worked through the last 20 levels this past year. I got to 55 in June and then took a break from lessons for a while before the final bit.

3 Likes

2 Likes

Shameless promotion:

The Beginner Club is currently voting on our next pick!

You should vote :wink:

I have a question. Until now, I wasn’t interested in this, because it didn’t seem like my type of story, but in Tofugu’s article I noticed a mention about Aomori dialect, which is apparently being explained in-universe. And I want this baby level introduction to Tōhoku dialect.
So, my question is, how large a part of the story is this? Idk, one new expression per chapter on average, less, more?
@NicoleRauch

The manga doesn’t lean too heavily into dialect.

There’s an occasional (rare) scene with an older character speaking with an accent so thick that the main character who moved to the area can’t understand what’s being said, and one of her local-to-the-area cousins has to translate for her. (In these scenes, it’s never baby level, even after getting a translation to Tokyo dialect.)

There may be common minor dialect bits that I’ve gotten used to to the point that I don’t even notice them, but that’d be entry-level dialect. I wouldn’t recommend the series it for the sole purpose of the dialect.

5 Likes

Fully agree with what ChristopherFritz said. Over the course of the 9 volumes, I remember like maybe 4 or so distinct scenes where people from the area (her uncle (twice at least), the guy in the apple orchard, the shopkeeper - did I miss any scenes?) were speaking to her in Tohoku dialect, but it’s mostly totally unintelligible to me (and to her as well btw). Maybe there are other light bits strewn into the language of friends and classmates, but at least I didn’t recognize it as specifically being Tohoku dialect but it rather felt like normal casual speech. I’m probably just too ignorant :rofl:

What I found much better in terms of understanding how the dialect works and what it does to standard Japanese was a beginner book club pick called “The mysterious town behind the mist”, chapter 1. That was only about the sound shifts, though, and not about dialect-specific words. The fun thing was, I could read this “aloud” in my head and was able to “reverse-engineer” the sound-shifts because I had enough reading experience and kinda knew what they were going to say and how they would phrase it. I would rather recommend that book (it’s a book, not a manga) if you want to get some exposure, but it doesn’t go very deep either on the dialect, it’s more something to add some flavour.
Have you tried to find a dedicated youtube channel for Tohoku-ben or something?

5 Likes

Oops, I may have used “baby level” too freely, I meant is as “introductory level”.

Anyway, awww, that’s too bad :frowning:

I really really liked the idea of new phrases being explained inside the plot, and not requiring outside checking.

I saw mentions that there are some language shenanigans in this one, but as I’ve just said, I really wanted this gimmick with a character explaining what’s being said. :stuck_out_tongue:

Oh no, not for me. First of all, I’m awful with auditory learning, podcasts and audiobooks, even in my native tongue, are pure suffering for me.
I sometimes grit my teeth if a channel is really interesting, but right now, I was looking for a pleasant solution :stuck_out_tongue:
And secondly, I’m learning best when there is some plot included. :sweat_smile:

Anyway, I’m disappointed, but it’s better to learn this before purchase and/or getting my hopes up, so thanks to you both for your answers! :sparkles:

5 Likes

This actually only happens in one chapter, sadly. (And, to disappoint you further: it’s an explanation on how to prune apple tree blossoms, so I guess it’s nothing like you imagined.) If you’re interested, I could find out which one it was, and you could read that on its own. The manga being slice-of-life, I don’t think there would be anything you don’t understand straight away (or could be explained in three sentences, I guess).

Ok, gotcha :wink:

2 Likes

well I thought it was an interesting…:disappointed:

also it happens more than once…of the top of my head there’s also the converstion about setting up a field for makoto to grow plants in

1 Like

Yes, I remember the scene with her uncle, but is there somebody translating? That part totally slipped my mind. Thanks for the reminder!

2 Likes

Chinatsu handles the translation for that one.

3 Likes