More oldies for me this week, from the quartet of Japanese greats:
西鶴一代女 / The Life of Oharu
1952, Kenji Mizoguchi
A 50yo prostitute who was once a lady-in-waiting at the court in Kyoto in late 17th century Japan, looks back on the last 30+ years of her life.
zzz
Another Mizoguchi film, another downer… poor Oharu was life’s favourite punching bag, it seems.
It’s more or less a long string of bad, bad things happening to one woman, with whatever fleeting moments of joy there are (don’t expect many, though), being there only to spite her before the next even worse wave.
For me it felt like it was a bit too much, though… too depressing and maybe not the best pick to start a new week of films.
But it is well staged (like a finely arranged theatre play), well acted (although the lead actress was perhaps a little too old to be playing the young girl) and expertly shot.
Similar to The Story of the Last Chrysanthemum it has mostly long takes in which the camera never gets close to the characters, and almost always pans sideways with smooth slow motions, much how like the women move around in the frame seemingly floating
7.5-8/10
宗方姉妹 / The Munekata Sisters
1950, Yasujirô Ozu
Setsuko and Mariko are the Munekata sisters, with a rather large age gap.
Setsuko is in an unhappy marriage and now Hiroshi, the man she loved is back after some 10 years abroad. Mariko tries to reunite them, but she may also be interested in Hiroshi.
zzz
It’s been a (relatively short, yet it felt long) while since the last Ozu film… it turns out I kinda missed his style
For those who don’t like his usual stuff, this one won’t change their minds… it’s pretty much more of the same
What it boils down to is the generational gap - now between siblings, rather than parents and children -, traditionalism vs modernism - again through the two sisters, with their father trying to establish a common ground - and marital woes - with multiple parties involved in the same entanglement.
But it did have a few “new” tricks, at least to me… there’s a quite surprising scene of domestic violence ( ) and then of course the outstanding part for Hideko Takamine as Mariko who was abso-effin’-lutely delicious here - seeing her so adorably playful this time around, after several other “serious” roles, was quite a shock… but in a good way. And it certainly looked like she was having tremendous fun throughout!
Kinuyo Tanaka, she was good too, but she felt a little uncomfortable having to smile so often, per Ozu’s usual requirements
(To be honest, all that smiling from everyone all the time can be a little tiring even for viewers.)
I can’t say I loved the ending (not the “twist” but the conclusion to the story) but I guess he didn’t want to go down the “obvious” route…
Oh, and it has lots of cats!
7.5-8 for the film, 11/10 for Hideko Takamine… again!
稲妻 / Lightning
1952, Mikio Naruse
Osei is a single mother of four - one son and three daugthers, each child from different fathers (!!!). The older sisters are (poorly) married, and the family is putting pressure on the youngest daughter Kiyoko, to marry with a man of better standing, a baker. But Kiyoko likes her independence and doesn’t much like her family.
zzz
Wait… that (“X must marry”) sounds a little like the plot of an Ozu piece, doesn’t it?
Only being by Maruse, adapting a novel from the same author as several other of his films, it has very little in common with Ozu’s works, painting a much bleaker picture.
There’s no kind and reconcilliatory paternal figure here, the family is torn apart by a suite of bad things than are made even worse by their own responses to the situations, and… much to my surprise, it did not end as I expected - it’s quite different even from other Naruse films.
It’s commendable for giving viewers an extremely well put together climax scene (the lightning in the title makes an appearance) and an actually clear (and not tragic!) ending, kinda like the clearing after a storm.
But somehow on the whole it didn’t draw me in as it seems to have done for others (looking at some IMDb and Letterboxd comments)… there was just too much happening and it felt even a little confusing at times (“who was that character, again?”, “how did those two suddenly…?”). Maybe it works better on a second watch?
7-7.5/10
あにいもうと / Brother and Sister
1953, Mikio Naruse
The already hard life of a rural family “across the river from Tokyo” (It might as well be an ocean between them ) is complicated futher when the unmarried older of two daughters comes home pregnant from the big city. The scandal threatens marriage prospects even for the younger sister. Having a brash and crude elder brother doesn’t make things any better.
zzz
Another adaptation from an apparently famous novel in Japan, this one worked better for me, compared to the previous Naruse outing.
The way the story flows made it relatively easy to feel for the characters - more so for the younger daughter than the older, but still; for the mother too, however (perhaps intentionally) not for the father or the older brother.
The down-beat, menancing atmosphere grows throughout and ends with a seriously violent scene when prejudices and double standards are finely laid out in the midst of a very one-sided fight.
Then the conclusion is ambiguous yet not all that surprising - there was zero room left for any sort of “happy” ending.
And again not quite surprising: Masayuki Mori in yet ANOTHER “bad guy” role How this dude was one of the most beloved actors of that period, I have yet to find out
Solid 8/10 this one.
悪い奴ほどよく眠る / The Bad Sleep Well
1960, Akira Kurosawa
Nishi marries the daughter of his boss, wealthy business man Iwabuchi. It is not a particularly happy moment as the corporate honcho and his minions are suspected of corruption and hounded by the press and the police.
The police investigation crumbles, but the businessmen are still tracked by an unknown individual.
zzz
In a very loose adaptation of Hamlet (it’s really just some elements of Shakespeare’s play), Kurosawa lays out a great tale of revenge while also putting the corporate greed and corruption in the spotlight.
Japanese mindset is a little difficult to understand, as company employees would rather commit suicide than rat out on their bosses. Somehow though, this doesn’t come off as exaggerated or unbelievable.
Not even the “hero” of the story - the one who’s out for revenge on his father’s suicide from five years prior - is presented in a glamorous light, as his choices end up hurting both himself and those he loves.
The film has a brisk pace at first, to the point of confusion early on as a lot of characters are introduced abruptly at the wedding scene (but it’s fine, things clear up eventually) then slows down to even humanize a bit the evil characters.
The ending may seem abrupt, but I thought the decision to not show exactly what happened was an inspired one, it worked better for me this way.
Acting is good throughout, in that Japanese exaggerated way. Mifune is excellent as always, while Masayuki Mori… well, here he is in yet another “bad man” role. I ain’t giving up though, I shall eventually run into a film where he’s a good guy
8.5/10
Also, watched an anime - もののけ姫 / Princess Mononoke (just okay, not great… but that’s how it is for me with most of these ) - and one of the stopmotion shorts from the JFF - Gon, the Little Fox (cute at first, sad by the end… as expected).