Try Japanese the Manga Way
1 Like
Text books in general have been absolutely useless for me. https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLwGjqS2iLnwV1lBfUo6VuWmMaWUJnxLMK and JP101 (thought I donāt like it IMO) are both much better for me. They do a better job of just getting the information out.
Genki seems to be overrated as THE go to textbook for Japanese.
2 Likes
I started with Genki and it didnāt work out very well. Right now, Iām 100 to 150 pages into finishing the Tae Kimās guide.
If I was to start all over again, I would suggest the Youtuber Japanese Ammo with Misa and the Tae Kimās Guide. The Tae Kimās guide has everything condensed into 1 place while Misa explains things in a very SIMPLE way. When I have something that I feel I donāt understand very well, I just go to Misaās videos and I normally get my ideas straight.
Take into consideration that Misa only has like 50 videos so you might not find the thing that youāre looking for there.
Never tried other textbooks.
2 Likes
Sheer willpower and a Japanese-like work ethic. Jokes aside, the first few chapters are pure suffering. Check out the the writing section if you havenāt already. There are some longer passages to read in later chapters that are more fun. Otherwise consider it extra time to work on things that have trouble with or just easy days until you get to new material.
Imabi has even less examples/practice sections than Genki and Tae Kimās guide has the least of them all. Japanese the Manga Way is mostly one panel to a grammar point as well, so itās not much better in that regard, but the comics do make it more fun as you progress through the book. Human Japanese has a lot of sample dialogues with audio and breakdowns, but depending on your progress youāre probably past a lot of it and the first volume is kana onlyā¦ Personally, I would just set a schedule and force myself through Genki, but Iām more of a traditional learner. As others have pointed out thereās tons of new age alternatives out there as well.
If youāre willing to compensate for the slog with reading materials check out the resources thread and consider something like a bilingual book, satori reader, nhk easy, ect. Iāve been finding childrenās reading materials a fun way to offset the suffering.
1 Like
Iām currently doing Genki as well (though Iām pretty sure youāre on the second one?), and I think the most valuable part of the series is the amount of exercises it has. I have both the textbook and the workbook, and by doing all the tasks I really feel that it helps solidify the grammar points. Iāve also had to realize that studying wonāt necessarily be fun. I understand that it might be a drag to force yourself through it, but I donāt think it will hurt to repeat things you already know.
With that said, textbooks arenāt for everyone! Weāre all different and require different tools to maximize our learning. I suggest trying out different resources until you find what works best for you. Personally Iām very fond of traditional textbook learning.
Yer. I hear you and I am a fan of traditional textbooks as well. I am thinking that I will persevere; just try to grind the grammar as much as possible and then go on to another resource. I do agree that the workbook and the questions are the most helpful part. I suppose it is just a matter of gritting your teeth and getting through it.
Thank you for the help everyone. 
Genki is more of a classroom textbook - it is assumed there that when learning new grammar you will have a teacher to explain it more in detail for you and you will get tasks to make sentences yourself with the grammar. Still, itās possible to use the textbook when solo studying as well. I think some grammar gets clearer once you start doing exercises related to it but if itās still unclear I suggest you complement Genkiās explanations with the ones provided on āA dictionary of basic Japanese grammarā. Thereās tons of examples and explanations for every nuance - tho for a beginner I donāt think itās necessary to know all the small details about every grammar, as long as you get the main point. I personally think Genki is a great learning material so as long as you read up more on the parts you donāt get using other materials, you should be fine keeping on using it 
1 Like
I feel like the workbook is very important. One of my main problems studying with the Tae Kimās guide is that it completely lacks exercises.
I might purchase the workbooks in the future ^^ Thereās 2, right?
1 Like
Yea the workbooks are pretty good, but you need to purchase a seperate book for the answers, which is like a master answer book for both the textbook exercises and the workbook exercises.
1 Like
I use Genki, and the explanations they give arenāt stellar, but what they do have that many other resources lack, are examples. The textbook itself has a review section after every chapter, and the workbook has A TON of examples and practice questions for every subsection in every lesson! So even if you donāt fully understand something while reading the explanation, after doing the reviews youāll surely understand it.
Also, Genki has this resource: Self-study Room offers a variety of online materials to support your learning with Genki textbooks.
1 Like
I just read the dialogues at the beginning, then check the translations to see if I was right (or how close to correct I was), then read the grammar points and move on to the next chapter.
But I also watch the Nihongonomori N5-N4 playlist. While things arenāt in the same order, there is still approximate overlap and great examples, in a quick format.
1 Like
My formula for Genki has become:
-
Listen to, then read dialogue, covering translation until Iāve worked out as much as I can;
-
Listen to + read vocab, covering translation and trying to translate myself before the audio file tells me;
-
Read grammar points;
-
Do workbook exercises with the grammar section open in front of me for regular referral. Cry at how long this step always takes;
-
Do main textbook exercises. If I can do any of the pair work exercises on my own, do those as well;
5.5. If any of the grammar points still arenāt clear, Google (though Iām starting to refer to Tae Kim more specifically);
- Kanji sections, which are a breeze thanks to WK but I still enjoy learning stroke order and doing translations.
Rinse and repeat for each chapter. Every so often Iāll go back and re-read earlier grammar points or re-listen to dialogues to make sure Iāve retained those lessons. I donāt really drill the vocab, because Iāve found a lot of it is covered in WK or whatever other exposure I have to Japanese.
3 Likes
I donāt follow. Every grammar point explanation has a multitude of example sentences, and the grammar practice section has dozens more, which you can listen to a native speaker pronounce. That doesnāt even count the workbook. Iām not sure Iāve seen another resource with so many examples for every grammar point.
I second the user who mentioned Japanese the Manga Wayā¦ itās a much much more fun book to read. I went through that whole book concurrently. But in that book youāre going to get 1 or maybe 2 examples only per grammar point and zero practice exercises.
Genkiās content is fairly boring, yes. I hate Mary and Takeshi just as much as you. But it is a very complete resource. If you stick with it thereās a lot of potential for solidifying what youāre learning.
My 2cents 
My formula for Genki I and II was:
- Read the dialogue as a sort of preview for upcoming grammar points
- Take notes on 1 or 2 grammar points a day, which involved rephrasing everything in my own words until I fully understood it, and writing practice sentences
- Simultaneously learn the vocab using Anki and Memrise
- Do the workbook exercises after finishing vocab and grammar, and try to rely solely on memory for the grammar points to further reinforce them
- Correct any workbook exercises as needed with the answer key
- Do the readings in the back of the book. Theyāre actually somewhat interesting and fairly good for reinforcing a variety of grammar points
I didnāt do the kanji writing practice since it would take extra time and Iām less interested in it currently. I also limited myself to a maximum of 2 weeks per chapter.
Now that Iām finished with the books but am in need of listening practice, I find myself returning to them to utilize the dialogues included on the CDs. There are transcripts for these dialogues in the answer key, so itās been a very valuable tool.
2 Likes
They sure know how to make money from desperate Japanese learners 
Thanks for the info!
Does anybody here study the grammar and vocab before reading/listening to the dialogue? Right now Iām just starting out with Genki 1 for review, but eventually I will get to the point where itās not review. I think I might get frustrated trying to understand the dialogue without knowing about whatās going to be in itā¦or maybe thereās not that much new stuff per chapterā¦idkā¦
As far as additional resources, Iām using www.mykikitori.com for additional listening practice and this memrise course for vocab drilling.
It depends on the chapter. Most chapters only seem to add a few points, however I recall one or two really dense chapters (at least for me).
Also, the dialogue at the beginning (if reading it, I donāt know about listening to it) is pretty easy to guess at, based on context. I wouldnāt worry too hard - whatever you donāt get, just acknowledge you donāt, move on to the grammar, and then come back and be āoh, thatās why that means that!āā¦ You just have to allow yourself to be wrong. Itās okay to make mistakes; weāre learning after all. ^^
[EDIT and UNRELATED: Iām pretty annoyed that Discourse changed something that will no longer let me make my favourite emoji to smile - itās now getting converted into a yellow smiley, even with the previously cancelling backslash in there. ~(O.O)~ ]
1 Like
If you find yourself thinking that you are suffering while reading Genki then it might be worth looking into other resources. Other people have suggested Japanese the Manga Way, which is a decent resource, but it does lack a lot of examples too. I think that book is better off as a supplement to a more dedicated grammar resource. Tae Kim is a little thin too, but each grammar lesson is relatively short to the point you could do one (or a couple) each day and not feel like youāre losing your mind from boredom. He gives a few examples, but nothing to practice which can be a problem for some people (although I think just reading native material and referencing your grammar sources is good enough practice).
You could try Imabi since quite a few people seem to like it and from what I hear its basically a more in-depth version of Tae Kimās guide, so thatās something to look into. But I think the most important thing is to find a grammar source that doesnāt make you feel like youāre suffering, otherwise you will just get burnt out on it and lose focus altogether.
Genki books are based very much on the Japanese system of drilling (over, and over, and over again). Which, given the percentage of Audio/Visual learners in the world, isnāt necessarily bad. The books are designed with a teacher in mind (not for self learning, although they can be used that way). In addition to conversation classes and language lab components that compliment the books.
If youāre just following the text - read each chapter three times. First, skim it/read it quickly. Second, read it through (light notations). Third, really read and dig in and take lots of notes. Do the examples along with the text.
You should also have the workbook for the text (green or orange, depending on if you have #1 or #2), which you should be doing after the third read-through (trying to do it without the aid of the text, but refer to the text as needed - making adjustments as you go).
Finally, it is expected that not only do you use the kanji and grammar of a given chapter, but also all previous kanji and grammar taught so that you can compose target sentences on your own (by way of a daily journal, writing practice, retention practice, etc).
It requires quite a bit of discipline to self-teach using books meant for the classroom. And youāll not see improvement unless you work on both of each of the passive and active skills (listening/reading and speaking/writing).
(I did 2 years of Japanese study in university via those texts in the classroom).
PS: ALWAYS have a printed copy of Tae Kimās Japanese on hand to leaf through!
Woah woah woah, assumptions much? I personally am enthralled by their budding romance ever since they finally managed to get that Kabuki date to work out (silly Takeshi, waiting at ććÆććć«ć instead of ć¢ć¹ćć¼ć¬ć¼!). Who knows what will happen next???
I make a point not to, because I like to try to figure out new vocab and grammar from context, and then refer back to it after learning the grammar points to check my understanding. However, I can see the value in doing it the other way around.
3 Likes