I am closing in on level 50 and have thought about quitting constantly. But i feel like i am too far in to quit. “If i quit, is there an alternative that isn’t annoying?” Is an question that i have yet to answer. I think i probably just fall into the camp that thinks learning kanji is just always a pain in the neck regardless of what path.
I have to say though it does have alot of issues.
Offering 5 words with the same meaning and not explaining the differences.
No indication on which words are spoken or more appropriate for formal writing.
3. 50% of the mnemonics just being about how kouichi and the shougen did this and that. So at level 50 i have a hundred stories about kouichi and shougun and cant even remember which kanji they were attached too because it was overused.
4. Because its recall based, alot of the words i dont remember unless i am prompted with the kanji infront of my face. Wish there was a sentence mode where it prompted you with a sentence instead for more context perhaps.
The only benefit i see in it now is:
Exposure from different sources is important for language learning. It counts as one source.
I am lazy. It offers a no thinking daily habit for me.
I don’t understand when you say “low-value misses”. けん and げん are different - in a test, you would fail if you wrote いげん. Likewise, writing “pastal” instead of “postal” makes the word in English completely incomprehensible, and it would be the same in Japanese. This is not a “low-value miss” - it is incorrect, period. There is no such thing as a low-value miss. However I do understand your frustration.
I would suggest you reset to level one and relearn the correct readings. I had a situation when I was making too many mistakes once I reached level 42, so I reset to level 1 and restarted, and took time to review errors before each session. I am at level 32, and feel it was 100% the right decision to reset. As you say, it is not reaching level 60; it is learning. For referrence I have been using Wanikani almost continously for over 6 years with perhaps 3 months in between breaks. Slow-learning is more effective that completing Wanikani in one year.
I also find the number of reviews you are doing very low - i am guessing you are not advancing through the lessons fast enough. My second suggestion is to do more lessons per day to average 100-150 lessons daily if you feel stuck and not progressing, provided you are not making too many mistakes.
Good luck - Wanikani is what made me able to read Japanese texts, where others may have given up.
Regarding missing rendaku being a “low-value miss”, I think that has some validity IF you are keeping WaniKani in what, imo, is it’s proper place.
IMO: Wanikani is crap at teaching Kanji. That is not what it is good at. Frankly, everything that purports to teach Kanji, except for actually using it for real communication, is crap. However what WaniKani is good at, is helping you get that first introduction to the characters, meanings, and related vocab. That will help you identify and use the character for real communication elsewhere. That is of tremendous value.
That also means, if Wanikani lets me see 青空 somewhere in native materials and I immediately know what it means, but I’m not quite sure if it’s read as あおぞら or あおそら, I don’t really care. Wanikani has done it’s job, now it’s time for repeated exposure to the word to finish the process.
Expecting Wanikani to let you 100% learn kanji and words is a recipe for disappointment and frustration. Using Wanikani as an aid towards learning kanji and words in the wild, is tremendously useful. And as such, being simply an aid, getting hung up on 100% perfection is counter productive, imo.
Nothing on WK is even close to “100% perfection” in terms of understanding, so I think this is an exaggerated take on what it means to set the bar at knowing how a word is read.
Either way, you’ll need to learn all of this stuff eventually if you want to improve. It’s just a matter of when.
I think I’m going down that path of getting things slightly wrong. I’m not going to reset back down to level 1 however. It took forever to get to 40, and I can’t even fathom getting back to 40. It was an ordeal and a half to get to 40 and itd be a nightmare to get back. There is no going backwards for me.
Don’t let perfection get in the way of capability. High accuracy is good, perfection is a waste of effort.