Bunpro x WaniKani advice

I’m steadily slogging my way up through WK, and to be honest mostly it doesn’t feel too much like a slog, even though I’m in the ‘painful’ levels. However it does seem to take up a lot of time. I do my 15 lessons a day and nearly always get through all my reviews.

Anyhow, WK isn’t what this post is about, I just wanted to say where I’m at in WK as it impacts my Bunpro practice. I started BP fairly early and for a while it was just terrible :scream: . Now I find it useful, but doing vocab (sync’ed with WK) and grammar takes a lot of time in addition to WK.

I try to read when I can and I really value BP for helping with that. In the last few months I have felt my learning begin to come together in a self-supporting way, like: you learn a verb in WK, you learn conjugation from BP or elsewhere, then you hear the word in say the ‘polite past’, or you read it and it all stitches together. I guess what I’m trying to say is that the idea of getting to WK mid or high levels without doing grammar seems sort of nuts to me now when I see how the combination of reading, listening and understanding really leverages up the time invested in learning vocab.

The problem I’m starting to feel is one (I think) of balancing effort. WK I find straightforward, in the sense that I learn and I mostly remember as long as I keep going. BP vocab can feel like a nightmare because in WK one tends to latch onto 1 ‘correct’ meaning for a kanji, whereas BP will ask you for any one of 10 different uses for the word ‘finish’ or ‘work’ or ‘open’ etc. I value it for that, but it is time-consuming. And then there’s the grammar reviews on top of that, more time.

The upshot is that just keeping ahead of WK and BP consumes a lot of time, and while I know that reading and really focused listening would help build a more complete and interwoven understanding, I’m often just too tired or I run out of time.

My experience to date, after 8 months, has been that the further I go the more it sort of magically ‘works’. The more little pieces or building blocks one learns in WK, the easier it becomes to learn more. For example, you’ve seen that radical/kanji in several different contexts, so when you learn it again in a new one, you’re only really learning the new ‘half’. Similarly with BP. Or watching anime, the ‘ah ha’ of: “oh, I didn’t know what that was but now I can hear that it’s -some word I know - plus - a conjugation pattern I know - plus - ‘shall we?’”.

My question then, finally…, is: keep up the WK and BP pace because it’s providing foundations for reading and listening, or back off the pace, focus more on reading and listening to consolidate what I’m learning?

Relatedly: I’m thinking of getting a conversation tutor, because I know I’m avoiding speaking. How do people find that? Does it work well? My understanding feels quite basic at the moment, so maybe it’s too early, but I wonder does it provide impetus for making use of what one learns?

Thanking you all in advance for your help!

I think as you get further in BP and WK, the thing that will really tie the room together like a good rug is any real-world reading you do.

For me, for example, どうやら and どうせ in BP sound so similar at first that I’m not sure how I’d be able to get them correct consistently without having come across Ayanokōji laconically using both of them in slightly different contexts in my reading. Similarly, it helped a lot with the later levels of WK to be able to be like “oh yeah!! I saw 桟橋 when the boat was docking, now here’s 桟 in my level 60 kanji lessons!” or “oh yeah, Koenji says 醜い to describe his classmates!”

The benefits of this start way earlier too, since chances are good that you can get into a positive feedback loop where your reading prepares you for some of what you’ll study in BP and WK and then vice versa.

So, if you’re feeling like reading more, here’s my permission to you to make the switch in priorities.

That said, it is true that your SRS work will make acquiring the stuff you’ve practiced easier, so if you’re still finding benefit in doing it, there’s no need to stop.

For speaking, A conversational tutor would definitely help, but aside from taking classes, I don’t have experience there. I talk to myself a bunch either in my head or out loud when I won’t bother people. If you’re like me, one suggestion for a low lift would be to try and do that in Japanese as much as you can.

Why are you learning Japanese? That should determine your focus. For me, I have to focus on everything (reading, writing, speaking, listening) as my spouse is Japanese. However, if you are visiting Japan soon, definitely try to do more speaking.

I use Wanikani and Bunpro. I had been using Wanikani for a while before getting a one-year Bunpro subscription for JLPT review. I do like Bunpro’s integration of Wanikani, but both platforms are a lot to do every day. Since I’ve done a lot of grammar review with it, I will probably take a break from Bunpro when my subscription is up and possibly use it for N2/N1 grammar review at a later date. I am only doing 5 words/kanji a day with Wanikani at the moment, but the words are less common after level 30.

For tutors, I have a once a week class, and it’s a great way to be accountable with your learning. I do some conversation, reading, homework review, etc. I do self-study from a textbook between classes. My classes are online as it’s cheaper than private classes would be where I live, and I would have to travel about an hour each way on public transport if I were to attend group classes. A lot of sites have free or reduced price trials, so it’s worth looking into. Remember that not every tutor may be a good fit for your learning style.

Also, I read. This is mostly manga. The book clubs on this forum are a good way to stay motivated with your reading, as well as to get support if you’re struggling with meaning or grammar. Reading has also really helped me improve for the JLPT, if that’s your focus.

A settings recommendation from me would be to switch your vocab cards off of cloze and make them translate in bunpro.

When they come from WK and you’re in your earlier stages of learning, doing the cloze sentence reviews for vocab is like miserably difficult and not really helpful. You’ll save yourself a lot of time just doing that

thanks! that’s great. I think I just need to grit my teeth and get more reading time in. And I’ll try talking in my head. At the moment a lot of my Japanese conversation is with my pets: “as for my dog, he is fat”, “as for my dog, he wishes to eat the cat’s food”…

Thank you! That’s helpful. My ultimate goal is to be able to speak and read, I have visited Japan with my daughter and we will return next year and it’s just such an interesting country that I would love to be able to have a more interactive experience. That might not be next year, but it would be nice to be able to use even a little of what I’ve learned to get beyond ‘please’ and ‘thank you’ !

Oh, interesting! You know, only yesterday I poked at the settings dropdown where is says “Cloze” and was wondering what all the other ones were. Great! If it saves some time then that’s more time to read or listen. And it’s nice to hear someone else describe BP as: ‘miserably difficult’ :slight_smile: it’s gotten to the stage where, when I actually get something right first time, I’m so surprised and delighted that I have to go off and give myself a treat as a reward!