Hey guys! Let’s talk about our beautiful club for a bit! ![]()
In the よつばと! Vol 1 thread, @seanblue gave the idea of creating an overlap of a weekend between chapters. This would allow us to have 2 full weekends to discuss each chapter. The more advanced members could move right away to the next chapter and the ones more delayed in their reading would still be able to catch up. I thought this was a wonderful idea and everyone seems to agree. Therefore, I decided to put it into action without creating a pool and risking losing any momentum.
Here’s the new schedule already posted in the よつばと!Discussion Thread:
Chapter 1: from the 1st of October until the 15th of October;
Chapter 2: from the 14th of October until the 22nd of October;
Chapter 3: from the 21st of October until the 29th of October;
Chapter 4: from the 28th of October until the 5th of November;
Chapter 5: from the 4th of November until the 12th of November;
Chapter 6: from the 11th of November until the 19th of November;
Chapter 7: from the 18th of November until the 26th of November;
Now let’s talk about the pool related to opening a new thread for each chapter. As for now, 36 people voted and 61% agreed to open a new thread. Since the discussion of the 2nd chapter already started, I think at least this one could continue to be connected to the current topic, as to avoid losing momentum. I suggested the idea of being possible for both Book Clubs to have a specific subcategory in order for everything to be better organized. The answer from the WK staff was a no.
It was also suggested to write the page number every time one asks a questions (hey, it was already in the book club rules… always read the rules!
).
So now I ask you guys what should we do ![]()
Should we finish this 2nd chapter in the current thread (not talking about the later ones) or should we immediately create a new one?
- Let’s finish this 2nd chapter in the current thread.
- We should create a new one immediately.
0 voters
Next: I honestly think there won’t be as many comments in future chapters. Eventually, we’ll get used to the speech used in the book/manga, so a lot of typical questions will end up disappearing. We’re going to divide the topics by chapters (as the pole determined). However, I think how this division works should be pondered later on. No matter the above pool’s results, I think it is logical to create a new topic only when the previous one is prone to get saturated We can’t predict if every individual thread will get saturated with only 1 chapter. The decision of opening a new one would be discussed before the start of the new chapter, of course.
What do you guys think we should do?
- I want each chapter to have its own thread.
- I want to decide later on if opening a new thread for the following chapter is justified.
0 voters
Let me know what you guys think! ![]()