Alright! The current pick will be finishing in February, such that we’ll be starting a new pick on the 20th. That means we’re coming up to voting season
I will be opening the vote on Wednesday, so please take the time over the next few days to look through the sample pages of our nominations (listed with links in the OP) and rate their comparative difficulties. I’ll check back through the thread today to make sure there aren’t any missing.
It’s helpful if you rate the majority of the picks, as we need to know which ones you think are harder than others comparatively.
If you have any last-minute nominations to submit, please try to do so before the end of the weekend, so that people have a few days to check them out. Sorry that this is quite a last-minute deadline, but we have enough nominations for a vote as is.
Recently, I’ve been reading some ongoing manga series. Typically I prefer to read series that are complete, although I mostly make an allowance for slice of life.
I was curious about the length and ongoing/competition status of the current manga nominations. The results:
Title
Volumes
Status
不可解なぼくのすべてを
4
ongoing
にじいろフォトグラフ
3
complete
北欧女子オーサが見つけた日本の不思議
5+1
ongoing
青の島とねこ一匹
3
ongoing
この美術部には問題がある!
13
ongoing
地縛少年 花子くん
14
ongoing
マギ
37+19
complete
僕のヒーローアカデミア
29
ongoing
デスノート
12
complete
名探偵コナン
98
ongoing
+チック姉さん
16
ongoing
日常
10
complete
Notes:
The status for にじいろフォトグラフ was determined by it no longer appearing in the monthly まんがタイムきららフォワード magazine (as per Wikipedia).
The first five volumes of マギ are free to read until 1/14. Check your preferred e-book retailer for 「マギ 期間限定 無料お試し版」 (no quotes).
Nichijou follows the everyday lives of various people in the town of Tokisadame, centering on the energetic Yūko Aioi, the bright and cheerful Mio Naganohara, the quiet and deadpan Mai Minakami, the anxious android Nano Shinonome, her young creator the Professor, and a talking cat named Sakamoto, along with an ensemble cast of characters. Random and/or outlandish events regularly occur throughout the series, mainly through the mundane situations each character goes through.
Peppe, popular resident of TV series “Terrace House” will start a new manga series in the upcoming issue 46/2019 of Weekly Big Comic Spirits titled “Mingo” about an italian otaku coming to Japan & finding love.
The story follows Mingo as he moves to Tokyo from Italy and tries to find love while being an otaku
This book was recommended to me a while back. i think the story is somewhat relatable since most people here want/have to go to japan(at least that’s my impression).
Pros and Cons
Pros
realism
slice of life
somewhat relatable character as he is much older than a school boy(AFAIK)
Cool, quiet, and mysterious, Koizumi-san is a transfer student who doesn’t get along with others. She is a ramen professional who searches for the best ramen every day! Ramen like this and ramen like that are all delicious! The authentic ramen graffiti is finally here!
If you are interesting in joining the next book club we run, you can (and should) vote!
Please look under “Current Proposals” in the first post for more details on each of the options, including links to sample pages which will help you gauge the difficulty.
Please take difficulty into account
Some people do find that reading a work they love or know already is inherently motivating / makes it easier, but please be realistic. Don’t just vote for your favourite story without looking at the samples yourself and comparing to others. Remember that both language and density contribute to difficulty.
Difficulty Scores
The number in front of each option is a difficulty score based on club members voting, where 1 indicates “no effort at all” and 5 indicates “so much effort my brain might explode”. These scores aren’t objective by any means, so please look at the sample pages of options you’re interested in.
When will we start and how many will we pick ?
We will likely begin reading on the 20th of February, one week after we finish reading ハイキュー!!. If a short manga (expected less than 8 weeks) wins we will also read the second place option afterwards without holding another vote.
List of "short" manga
At a guess, the following manga would be considered ‘short’. This is purely based on a quick look at the contents page - I’ll check any manga in the running more carefully once we have some votes in.
FukaBoku: Love Me For Who I Am
Nordic Girl Åsa
Rainbow-Coloured Photograph
This Art Club has a Problem!
Toilet-Bound Hanako-kun
You can vote for up to 4 options.
[2.36] FukaBoku: Love Me For Who I Am
[2.59] Rainbow-Coloured Photograph
[2.56 ] Koizumi-san Loves Ramen
[2.71] Nordic Girl Åsa
[3.12] Ao’s Island and a Cat
[2.31] Nichijou
[2.68] This Art Club has a Problem!
[2.64] Toilet-Bound Hanako-kun
[2.54] Magi
[2.57 ] Plastic Elder Sister
[2.84] My Hero Academia
[ 2.71] Death Note
[3.43] Great Detective Conan
[3.11] Scary Lessons // Book
[2.50] Ogawa Mimei’s Collection of Children’s Stories // Book
0voters
You can adjust your vote at any time by clicking ‘Show Vote’.