Asia/Helicopter radical is wrong

confusing,

Asia or Helicopter?

I mean, I’m very happy to criticize the mnemonics but in this instance this does look like the ‘helicopter’ radical but with an additional line at the bottom. Why not have the mnemonic build on the previously learned radical?

They’re referencing the other, similar-looking radical 芀 that’s introduced earlier:

ahh nvm i get it now

If it helps with your understanding, the reason they’ve called it “Asia” is because as a kanji, it’s used to represent Asia, since it’s the first kanji of äșœçްäșœă‚ąă‚žă‚ą. Actually, it quite frequently shows up in ateji words to represent the あ sound.

I have my own mnemonic. It looks like a Tie Fighter toy from Star Wars, straight out of a factory from Temu in Asia

Also as a phonetic component in kanji, like ç›Č攖.

It used to be called Tie fighter, long ago before massive overhaul. tbh, I didn’t know that thing is call “tie”; I learned it from WaniKani.

äșœäșș isn’t a person from Asia and isn’t a helicopter driver. Though 東äșœ is indeed East Asia.

I think the image here could be the cause of confusion
 a helicopter with a bar in the bottom? The bar is written Asia, yes, but the written text shouldn’t be counted as an image.

Interestingly enough, iirc, originally, it was indeed called “Tie Fighter” radical.
But then, somewhere in early 2020s, WK decided to do The Big Renaming – and lots of radicals were renamed
 trunky_rolling

P. S. Got ninja’d by @polv trunky_rolling

I always thought it looks more like an Asiatic lantern. Works for me anyway.

TIE Fighter. Stands for “Twin Ion Engine”. But yeah, the phrase “TIE fighter” only gets used once in the original trilogy, by Lando in Return of the Jedi.

I must never have even looked at the picture because I don’t remember a helicopter coming into it at all. I saw that radical, I saw “asia,” and I immediately went “Yep, that’s a Chinese lantern.”

I’m very glad whatever Star Wars nonsense that was has been removed.

IMG_5305

1 Like