Are 一段 verbs a closed class?

Not sure if this is the right place to ask this since this is more of an “abstract” question about grammar, but it’s something that I was thinking about recently. I know that 五段 verbs are an open class (to an extent), with stuff like ググる and サボる having been created relatively recently, the former especially, but I haven’t seen anything similar with 一段 verbs.

In case you don’t know what open and closed classes are, they’re terms that refer to the ability of word classes in a language (nouns, verbs, adjectives, stuff like that) to accept new words. Open classes are able to accept new words, closed classes aren’t. An example of an open class in English would be verbs: new verbs are being invented/coined all the time in English, so English verbs are an open class. On the other hand, prepositions are very much a closed class. There are a finite number of prepositions and there aren’t any new ones popping up anywhere (from what I can tell at least).

If you know of any new 一段 verbs, let me know! I’d be very interested to see them.

4 Likes

An interesting thought. I’ve also heard the same thing about adjectives - い-adjectives are closed, while な-adjectives are open. You can make a new 五段 verb easily enough by taking the last mora and changing the vowel sound to う, so Barak Obama becomes オバむ, Google becomes ググる, and so on and so forth, but yeah, I can’t really picture how you’d coin a new 一段 verb…

1 Like

From what I’ve looked up, it appears Japanese verbs in general are considered closed regardless of 五段 or 一段. There are some people debating whether or not the examples you mention mean that verbs are opening up, but they all mention that it’s not the norm. Nouns are pretty open, though.